It had been a while since I’d ventured to the PET Dairy section of the freezer aisle at my local supermarket, but their new Double Fudge Swirl was something that called my name from a far; especially given the epic swirls I’d seen in some of their other flavors. This one is described as vanilla flavored ice cream with fudge pieces swirled with butter fudge. The first two components were pretty straightforward. PET’s premium vanilla is simple, effective, and played well with the accompanying chocolate chips. As you can see from the picture below, the obvious highlight of this box was the butter swirl found concentrated near the middle. This viscous, fudge sauce is so overwhelming that it drowned out everything else involved in the bite, but that’s okay with us considering the taste. We didn’t necessarily pick up on much butter flavoring, but when combined with the other ingredients, this one was enough to warrant a B.
Where I Found It: Walmart
Grade: B
