The last time I was in Wegmans, I noticed they had released two limited flavors, Nutter Batter and S'mores, to their premium line of ice creams. Seeing how both of these are very calorie heavy (300+), my hopes were high that they would pack a lot of flavor and mix-ins. Nutter Batter is “Vanilla Ice Cream with Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Caramel, and Peanut Butter Swirls” After lifting the lid you get to see everything that the label explains. There is not much of the vanilla base that is shown because of the massive amount of swirls and little globs of peanut butter cookie dough. I found that aspect very neat because I have never seen that in an ice cream before. Picture yourself eating the peanut butter cookie dough; that is the best way to describe the combination.
After the first bite I was blasted with the rich amount of complementary flavors from the peanut butter swirls and globs of peanut butter cookie dough, which had a soft texture and great aftertaste that really combined well with the peanut butter swirl.
As I continued to plow through this pint the vanilla base started to stand out the more I tried. It had a very nice vanilla and cake batter taste to it. The way Wegmans combined the two flavors really made it stand out. The caramel was also a great addition. As a peanut butter ice cream fan, this is one of the better ones I've had.
Where Bob Found It: Wegmans
Bob's Grade: A