While we typically review premium and super-premium ice creams, it’s hard for us to resist anything with Key Lime Pie in the title. Our lack of self-control led us to covering this carton of Edy’s Key Lime Pie as part of their Slow Churned Yogurt Blends lineup. At only 120 calories per serving, fitting a cup of this into your diet couldn’t be easier. Labeled as a cultured frozen dairy dessert, coupled with the slim nutrition facts, left us skeptical from the start.
As we scooped some into a bowl, the graham cracker swirl was far larger than we had anticipated. Our first few bites were interesting to say the least. The feel and taste of the base was much as advertised; landing somewhere between a low-calorie frozen dairy dessert and actual flavored yogurt while providing a nice level of tartness from the Key Lime flavoring. The large chunks of graham cracker crust was enough to bring this odd creation up to average.
Where I Found It: Ingles Market
Grade: C
