Or maybe they have something to do with vampires. Hm. Come to think of it, that might explain a few things, actually...
Well, if I've learned anything from being a fangirl myself (though admittedly more of the sci-fi genre) it's that you always look for common ground when dealing with bloodthirsty devotees. That, and no sudden movements. So, Twi-hards, sink your teeth into THIS (while the rest of us casually stroll off in this direction):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8ff8e/8ff8e5cb1f6d9e489976faf4f9c0aed7527d09ad" alt=""
As you can see, there are two crucial elements to most Twilight cakes:
1) edible photo paper, and
2) lots of black icing.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6e33a/6e33abf271da8428a7d913487399ae52e556812e" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1f38f/1f38fd6f23a7ff62a7203d1d83cd58261dea11c4" alt=""
Well, better get back to the formula, I suppose. Only, what's that you say? You want MORE black icing? Nooo problem:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d0b13/d0b137eeee1de7912c439b00fb7af3b9c8988311" alt=""
You know, for vampire-themed cakes these things have been awfully blood-free.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ae502/ae502f5554d98a1a68c08725b7ee1b04bc77be41" alt=""
(Yes, I know that Forks is the name of the town in the story. That's hardly an explanation, though.)
As with all cakes, the most important thing to remember when ordering a Twilight design is that nothing beats a little forethought, balance, and beautifully scripted text:
[Pro tip: if you're going to scratch guide lines into the icing, keep in mind that airbrushed icing is white underneath.]
And lastly, choosing the right text for your tribute cake is also key:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3b6c7/3b6c759eee56007e52ff83c9c87bc6610656de4f" alt=""
Er.
Yeeeahh...so...
Happy Birthday!
Or would it make more sense as an anniversary cake? [evil grin]
I hate to admit it, Giselle P., Katelynn B., Emily S., Jennifer T., & Itzkeleen, but I think the first Twilight Wreck I posted still takes the cake. (Keeping in mind that only the professional cakes count, of course; there are tons of hilarious amateur jobs out there.)
- Related Wreckage: The Twilight of our Discontent