.

Showing posts with label Perry's. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Perry's. Show all posts

READER REVIEW: Mo’s Review of Perry’s Caramel Cup Craze

I went to college in Upstate New York, where, as anyone who’s spent a fair amount of time in the region will attest to, the winters can be downright brutal. In fact, the weather got so cold at times that I actually found myself going weeks on end without eating ice cream for fear that doing so might cause my insides to frost over. But no matter how cold it got, I’d eventually come to miss my ice cream, at which point I’d head over to Wegmans and pick up a carton of Perry’s.


Years later, I came upon an amazing discovery while venturing over to a not so convenient but somewhat local Wegmans: Perry’s ice cream is actually available in New Jersey. I didn’t think this was possible, but sure enough, with a visit to Wegmans (a treat unto itself) came the opportunity to stock up on one of my all-time favorite brands.


Since I’ve been on somewhat of a caramel kick lately, I decided to dig into Caramel Cup Craze, a flavor described as “vanilla ice cream with caramel swirls and mini caramel cups.” Now if you’ve never had Perry’s ice cream before, the following may be a little difficult to grasp, so I’ll do my best to explain: The base had that unmistakable richness and creaminess Perry’s is known for. There’s just something about the way Perry’s makes ice cream that results in wonderful airiness and flavor, and Caramel Cup Craze is no exception. And while the base itself is satisfying on its own, the swirls and cups do a fantastic job of infusing some strong caramel flavors into the vanilla without going overboard on sweetness.


Of course, the fact that Perry’s is fairly generous on the mix-ins helps this flavor shine. The caramel cups are more than abundant, and they serve the dual purpose of enhancing the vanilla while offering a nice degree of textural contrast.


You know how sometimes you build something up in your head and eventually wind up disappointed when you realize you overhyped it? Yeah, that didn’t happen here. After many years of longing for Perry's, I was convinced that the ice cream wouldn't end up tasting as good as I remembered it, but Caramel Cup Craze truly exceeded my expectations. And as an added bonus, this time I got to eat it without freezing my tail off during the heart of winter in Upstate NY. I’d call that a win-win situation all around.


Where Mo Found It: Wegmans
Mo's Grade: A

READER REVIEW: Arjun's Review of Perry's Cookie Dough

Since there are not too many Perry’s reviews on this site, an introduction to the company is in order: Perry’s was founded in Akron, NY in 1918 and is a mainstay in the upstate area. Their ice creams cover the gamut from classics and standards to novelty flavors that celebrate the Buffalo Bills, Sabres, and Panda Paws. The company seems to stick to a small regional radius, covering 30 counties.


As it is my favorite flavor, I compare companies through their cookie dough offerings. The box promises “cookie dough ice cream with loads of cookie dough pieces and chocolate chips.” At 170 calories per half cup serving, it falls in line with the majority of Perry’s ice creams. This particular cookie dough differs from its competitors by utilizing a cookie dough ice cream base instead of a vanilla one. The cookie dough pieces are the sterling quality of this flavor. Each individual piece is gooey and contains the perfect amount of sweet. Combined with the chocolate chips, they deliver on the mix-in flavor enhancement. By themselves, the cookie dough pieces are superior to the ones found in Edy’s and Turkey Hill’s cookie dough offerings. However, the flavor is held back overall by the seemingly creative ice cream base. Perry’s would have been better off with a regular or French vanilla base (both of which they do very well). If they had nailed the cookie dough base, this flavor would be dynamite, but it is not to be.


I encountered an issue with the surface ice cream melting a tad too easily. The rest of the carton was preserved, but my brother and I found a soupy quality to the surface that was slightly off-putting.


Perry’s has many creative and standard offerings that are worth trying if you are ever in Perry’s region. Cookie dough incorporates some of the company’s creativity, but the real hit is those cookie dough pieces.


Where Arjun Found It: Wegmans
Arjun's Grade: B

READER REVIEW: Arjun's Review of Perry's Brownie Sundae


Perry’s is the Akron, NY ice cream outfit that I always make sure to scoop and enjoy whenever in Upstate New York. They do the standards, classics, and a few of their own creations. Brownie Sundae seems to be a combination of a classic and creation, promising a French Vanilla with a fudge swirl and brownie dough pieces, coming in at 170 calories per half cup serving.


Perry’s nailed the sundae flavor and feel with the fudge swirl, brownie pieces, and softened ice cream. It delivers the feeling that you have created this concoction from a create your own sundae bar. That feeling is apparent in the texture of the ice cream, obvious richness of the swirl, and gooeyness of the brownie pieces. The brownie pieces are abundant and scattered evenly and they reflect the texture of a chocolately brownie. Perry’s excels at the mixins a la cookie dough and small chocolate chips. Add the chocolate brownies to that list.


You will never bend or break your spoon digging into a bowl of Perry’s. If you prefer higher butterfat ice creams, you might find yourself discouraged by the softer texture of the French Vanilla base, which is the defining quality of the surface area. Thankfully, the ice cream below the surface does not melt quickly. The softness works well with the swirls and brownie pieces in the sundae construction. In comparison to other companies that fancy themselves as “premium,” Perry’s ice cream is the softest and quickest to disappear. In this particular flavor, it works beautifully because soft ice cream fits a sundae motif.


Where Arjun Found It: Wegmans
Arjun's Grade: B

READER REVIEW: Mo's Review of Perry's Sponge Candy

I'm a total sucker for limited edition ice cream flavors - especially those produced by my favorite brands. So when Perry's announced that it would be releasing a new Sponge Candy Ice Cream to celebrate its 95th anniversary, this flavor immediately shot up on my radar. And lo and behold, several weeks later I found myself happily staring at a carton of this new concoction on a pilgrimage to Wegmans.


The flavor is described as "caramel sugar flavored ice cream with caramelized sugar swirls and sponge candy pieces." Now I'm going to be honest for a second here: Before I actually sampled this flavor, I didn't really know what Perry's meant by "sponge candy." From the picture on the carton, it looked like something chocolate-based, but I really didn't know what to expect. Still, I figured anything with the word "candy" in it couldn't be too bad.


When I first peeled back the lid, I was greeted by a nice caramel swirl and several pieces of that mystery sponge candy poking through the top. And the deeper into the carton I dug, the more impressed I grew with the ratio of mix-ins.

Now let's talk flavor. The caramel base offers the creamy richness Perry's is known for. Before I got a chance to try the ice cream, I found myself wondering whether the caramel base combined with the caramel swirl would prove to be too sweet for my taste, but that most definitely didn't end up being the case. The base boasts a nice caramel flavor without coming off as too sugary, and the sponge candy pieces add a really nice level of contrast.


So about that sponge candy: If you've ever been fortunate enough to sample a Cadbury Crunchie bar, you'll know exactly what to expect. The candy pieces basically taste like hard carmelized sugar coated with rich milk chocolate. The great thing about sponge candy, so I've discovered, is that the center sort of melts in your mouth before the chocolate completely dissolves, leaving you with a very indulgent aftertaste. And although the sponge candy pieces featured in this flavor are darn good in their own right, the caramel ice cream takes the concept to a whole new level.


So there you have it: I'm officially a fan of sponge candy, and of Perry's Sponge Candy ice cream. If you're able to get your hands on this limited edition find, it's well worth your while.

Where Mo Found It: Wegmans (Manalapan, NJ)
Mo's Grade: A