.

Showing posts with label Starbucks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Starbucks. Show all posts

REVIEW: Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte


This transition from Fall to Winter has seen it's fair share of pumpkin-inspired offerings. Nearly every major manufacturer rolled out some type of flavor based around the bright orange gourd. The majority of companies stuck to the proven pumpkin pie strategy, but some broke away from the mainstream. Ben & Jerry's went the cheesecake route with their Pumpkin Cheesecake, while Blue Bell incorporated candied pecans and a cinnamon-honey-praline sauce inside their Spiced Pumpkin Pecan. A bit late to the party seeing as how it's nearly mid-November, Starbucks has introduced a new take on pumpkin ice cream.


The Pumpkin Spice Latte beverage has a near cult following, so the corporate minds at Starbucks have decided to use that as the basis for their next limited edition ice cream flavor. They've taken their patented coffee ice cream and have combined this with pumpkin spice base to embody their prized drink in ice cream. Unlike any other offering found this season, the unique combination of pumpkin and coffee should provide the perfect parting gift to this past season. After removing the green-rimmed lid, the dueling bases are barely distinguishable. The slight difference in shade is the only sign that this isn't your standard coffee flavor from Starbucks. Even the scent rising out of this pint is reminiscent of past pints of Starbucks.


Void of any mix-ins, the 220 calories per serving seems a bit on the high side, but after plunging my spoon into the ice cream, the density is along the lines of other super-premium pumpkin selections. It takes a few minutes to melt down enough to be able to scoop out a spoonful. Seeing as how the two individual ice creams are so intertwined, it's nearly impossible to determine exactly what you're getting inside each bite. The pumpkin portion is mild, possessing a well balanced flavor with the perfect amounts of both spice and sugar. But the real highlight of this pint is the result of combining the pumpkin base with the gourmet coffee ice cream.


None of my complaints with the Starbucks Ice Cream corporation has been with the quality of their coffee base. It's always full-bodied, complex and overly flavorful. If you appreciate a cup of high-quality coffee, this will hit home with you. The combination is a near spot-on representation of the actual drink. I've had my fair share of hot pumpkin spice lattes this season, but seeing as how those are being phased out to make room for peppermint, this ice cream will have to hold me over until next year. If you are a fan of the beloved Starbucks beverage, this will not disappoint.


Where I Found It: Target

REVIEW: Starbucks Mocha Cookie Crumble Frappuccino


After my distaste for Starbucks signature Java Chip Frappuccino, it took a limited edition pint to persuade me to sample another selection. I've always considered Ben & Jerry's Mud Pie as an underrated flavor and Starbucks has seemingly ripped off the idea, using their gourmet coffee ice cream instead of the standard Ben & Jerry's base. The purple, limited edition label describes their version, Mocha Cookie Crumble Frappuccino, as swirled coffee and chocolate ice creams with chocolate cookie pieces.


Even in my disappointing experience with their Java Chip Frappucinno, I still enjoyed their coffee base, which allows the unmistakeable taste of gourmet coffee beans to come through. Using a surprisingly accurate image, the first layer looks nearly identical to the picture printed on the lid. Much like Mud Pie, Mocha Chip Crumble Frappuccino has a marbled design, with splotches of chocolate cookies in between. Containing 230 calories per serving, this premium ice cream was plenty dense as I plunged my spoon into the first layer.


Grabbing a bit of the marbled combination of chocolate and coffee ice creams first, I'm surprised at how well the dueling bases work together. The somewhat-simple dark chocolate base comes together with the taste of gourmet coffee to create a complex flavor much better than just their standard coffee ice cream. Even though it's swirled with a strong chocolate, the highlight is still the floral bitterness of the high quality coffee beans. Because of the high calorie count, the ice cream remains dense and melts slowly in my mouth, allowing the complimenting flavors to completely commingle.


If the double bases inside this pint hadn't won me over, the super-soft pieces of chocolate cookie sealed the deal. These tidbits of flaky, moist cookie were a major upgrade from the slivers of fudge in Java Chip Frappuccino. Acting as Oreo impersonators, these chunks make their way into nearly every bite and break apart so easily they resemble some of the cookie swirls I've seen from other manufacturers. This limited edition offering was able to lockdown a much higher ranking than it's fudge chip infused counterpart.


Where I Found It: Kroger
Grade: B

REVIEW: Starbucks Java Chip Frappuccino


Back before the Starbucks brand had aspirations for world-wide domination, they used to produce one of the most delicious ice creams I've ever had. Letting Dreyer's handle all the dirty work, they produced some handiwork from the heavens called Mud Pie. Soon after becoming obsessed with this creation of chocolate sandwich cookies & fudge swirls in creamy coffee ice cream, Starbucks untied the knot with Dreyer's and began to allow Unilever to begin producing their frozen products. In the process, they decided to dump my beloved Mud Pie and I've been boycotting their ice cream ever since. Even limited edition and seasonal offerings haven't been enough to make me want to bury the hatchet.


I hadn't tried the new formula that Unilever had employed since they made the switch back in 2009, but I decided to start with one of their more straightforward flavors. The Java Chip Frappuccino has had widespread success in Starbucks locations worldwide, and nearly everyone has had a least of sip of somebody's, so I grabbed a pint for myself. Not terribly complicated, this was described as, "Coffee ice cream with dark chocolatey chunks."


After dislodging the lid, the first layer looks luscious and littered with large chunks of dark chocolate. The mocha scent meanders up and out of the beige-colored base. Being well versed in the world of coffee ice creams, I grabbed a large gob on my spoon to see how it could hold up to the competition. The gourmet beans and proven methods utilized by Starbucks are evident from the start. This doesn't taste like a gas station cup of joe, but instead gives you all the taste of that authentic five dollar beverage that would be made by a real Starbucks barista. With the accompaniment of an above average mix-in we could really have a winner.


But here's where the formula begins to fall off. Starting with their scrumptious coffee ice cream, a nice chocolate mix-in with a drizzle of chocolate and whipped cream swirling about would have been the appropriate approach to this flavor. Instead, Starbucks and Unilever settle on a slew of dark chocolate chunks and leave it at that. The dark chocolate plays nicely with the coffee, but I really dislike hard fragments of fudge in ice cream. The lack adding any real texture and these are just large enough to hinder the whole experience. You can't chew them without cracking a tooth and they don't deliver that high quality, dark chocolate aftertaste I was anticipating after allowing them to melt down.


As I continued my way through a few more bites, I couldn't help but hate how corporate America had taken advantage of the average consumer. They were selling thousands of these pints purely off the fact they were utilizing the Starbucks logo. I'm sure McDonald's could start unleashing a line of McFlurry inspired ice creams that would fly out of grocer's freezers simply by using the golden arches logo, but that doesn't mean they'd worthy of a thumbs up. Perhaps I'm still bitter they gave the boot to Mud Pie, but I just can't give this one the go ahead.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: D

READER REVIEW: Winston's Review of Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte


Being a big Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte (PSL) fan, and a huge fan of most things seasoned with pumpkin spice, I nearly performed backflips when the Ice Cream Informant announced the launch of Starbucks “Pumpkin Spice Latte” Ice Cream, actually found a pint, and reviewed it with a “B”. It took me around a month to find it after he reviewed it (believe me, I looked high and low), and I decided to hold off on gorging myself until recently, as I’m not particularly fond of caffeine consumption in the evenings.


Lifting the lid revealed an ocean of matte orange ice cream without any particularly exciting swirls or solids. This comparatively less stimulating eye candy certainly didn’t surprise me, as the hot beverage is no more than a sweetened latte with the addition of pumpkin spice and optional whipped cream. I salivated at the anticipation of a remarkably rich coffee ice cream and at the end of a four month abstinence of all things pumpkin spice. The first bite revealed a mild coffee base with lighter notes of pumpkin spice, a strong cream presence, and a below average sweetness. Nothing impressive, and my senses certainly weren’t aroused. The second bite provided similar returns. Confusion ensued; the initial experience did not parallel the pumpkin spice richness of a traditional PSL, nor did the sweetness or coffee notes match that of any traditional Starbucks latte. Third, fourth, and fifth bites deep into the pint revealed an interesting color contrast in the pint: swirls of light brown ice cream (presumably coffee) amongst orange (presumably pumpkin spice). Unfortunately, the two flavors seemed indistinguishable, and they resulted in a similarly comparatively bland experience as the first and second bites.


Shocked at my findings, I rushed my pint upstairs to my wife, also a fanatic of all things sweet. After one bite, she had no interest in a second. To give you an understanding of the significance of her reaction: my wife absolutely loves PSL’s, is a huge fan of coffee ice cream, and she was hungry at the time of the taste test.


I decided to allow the pint to soften, thaw and give it a second change. Perhaps, like some gelatos, it’s twice as good when slightly melted. Unfortunately, even though the dessert softened, it still didn’t portray strong coffee notes, lacked real sweetness, and simply tasted more like a mildly seasoned cream-rich dessert. Compared to Haagen Dazs coffee ice cream and Ben and Jerry’s coffee ice cream base, this base is far less rich, and didn’t seem to be nearly as sweet. I’m going to assume I’ve been spoiled by these two brands though, as well as their higher calorie contents (Starbucks PSL: 220kcal, Haagen Dazs Coffee: 260kcal, Ben and Jerry’s Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz Buzz: 260kcal) Further, while Starbucks’ PSL Ice cream base, I suppose, isn’t 100% coffee (it’s a blend of pumpkin spice and coffee Ice Creams), its beverage counterpart certainly is close to 99.99% coffee (latte) and 00.01% pumpkin spice powder. In essence, the experience from the beverage logically shouldn’t and does not carry over to the dessert.


Because The Ice Cream Informant endured a more positive experience with this dessert than I did, and because we both enjoy PSL’s and have somewhat similar tastes in ice cream, I’m going to assume that my pint probably doesn’t reflect the quality of all of Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte ice creams. Still though, I suggest PSL lovers proceed with caution, as my overall experience proved to be a general disappointment. Did it taste good? I suppose. Was it great? Absolutely not.


Where Winston Found It: Giant Eagle
Winston's Grade: C