.

Showing posts with label Mayfield. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mayfield. Show all posts

REVIEW: Mayfield Birthday Cake


In an attempt to branch out to some other brands, I reviewed a carton of Mayfield's Snickerdoodle a few weeks back. Recently I ran across some pint-sized portions available at a super-low price, so I decided to sample a flavor that I wouldn't normally purchase if it were in a larger container. My first experience had been pleasant enough to convince me to try their version of Birthday Cake ice cream, sugar cookie flavored ice cream with a big blue icing swirl and colored butter cream flecks. The only other sugar cookie base ice cream I've had the pleasure of experiencing acted as the foundation inside Christmas Cookies from Blue Bell, so hopefully Mayfield's version can have close to the same effect.


The fact that Birthday Cake only contains 150 calories per serving could be reason for concern, especially considering the weightlessness of the pint despite being full inside. Judging by look and calorie count, this seems to be of similar quality to that of Blue Bunny's Birthday Party. Yet again, the lack of actual birthday cake pieces which Blue Bell and Turkey Hill managed to include, would have been worth the influx in calories. With the top removed, the first layer is manilla-tinted, with hints of the thick blue icing swirl and multicolored butter cream flecks showing through to the top. Unfortunately, as I began to gather some of the beige base onto my spoon, I found the sugar cookie flavored ice cream had an unusual crumbly texture, usually consistent with low-quality ice cream.


The overly-sweetened base tended to have an artificial flavoring that had a bit of a cake batter taste, but finishes with a taste closer to it's intentions of sugar cookies. Although I was satisfied with the consistency found in Snickerdoodle, the base used in Birthday Cake just wasn't as smooth as I was hoping. Mayfield attempted to make up for this fact by adding a large amount of the icing and sprinkles. Very similar to the swirl and flecks used in Blue Bunny's Birthday Party, the butter cream sprinkles add a bit of texture, along with a burst of additional sugar. But the best, and sweetest part of this pint, comes in the form of the thick, bright blue icing careening throughout this container. The taste is identical to authentic icing you'd find on a birthday cake, but fails to impersonate the actual texture. The end result can't quite manage to overcome it's brother from Blue Bunny, or any other birthday cake flavor for that matter.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: F

REVIEW: Mayfield Snickerdoodle


The bright yellow cartons of Mayfield ice cream always catch my eye when I'm browsing the freezer aisles. I've always assumed that this was a low-quality, mass production operation that based their company on quantity sold rather than quality involved. But lately, this Braselton, Georgia based dairy has been placing some impressive sounding selections into circulation. Born and bred in the South, Mayfield makes a long list of products, including milk, sweet beverages, cottage cheese and of course, ice cream. After being enticed by flavors such as Blueberry Cream Pie and Peppermint Stick, I ultimately decided on Snickerdoodle to act as my first sample.


I've always been envious of those who had the opportunity to try Ben & Jerry's Snickerdoodle Cookie, so this was a chance for me try a flavor based on one of my favorite confections. After pulling off the yellow lid and removing the plastic seal, the first layer leaves a lot to be desired. Containing only 150 calories per half cup serving, this seems to be consistent with companies like Edy's. Although not marketed as a seasonal offering, Snickerdoodle cookies always tend to remind me of holidays spent with family. The cinnamon cookie flavored base breaks away easily as my spoon begins to scoop out a big bowl.


I secure a sample of the base ice cream and dig in. Although it's overly sweet, the cinnamon cookie aspect brings about some spice to balance out the overall flavor. The density is comparable to that of Blue Bunny or Turkey Hill, lacking the gummy texture of frozen dairy dessert. It doesn't take long to begin melting down, but still should provide a suitable foundation for the actual chunks of cookies. Although I was hoping for some homemade hunks of Snickerdoodle, these weren't entirely up to my standards. Completely uniform in size, these small tidbits were closer to cookie dough in appearance than actual baked cookies.


These were denser than standard cookie dough, but contained the same granular texture as they break down, a trait that I've grown to take enjoyment from. Bursting with cinnamon and butter, these bits of Snickerdoodle compliment the cinnamon cookie base efficiently enough. Although I would have loved an incorporated swirl, for only 150 calories per serving, this was still pleasant. I'll definitely keep an eye out for some of their more interesting flavors to bring on board to the blog in the future.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: D

REVIEW: Mayfield Blueberry Cream Pie


As some of you may remember, I dabbled in some of the unique flavors that Mayfield Dairy had to offer at the end of last year. Their Snickerdoodle, Birthday Cake and Candy Bar creations all fell significantly short of my high standards, but after seeing the description of cream cheese flavored ice cream with a blueberry swirl and sugar pie pieces referred to as Blueberry Cream Pie, I was willing to give them another shot. Blueberry isn’t an inspiration you see used all that often when it comes to ice cream, especially outside of a cheesecake themed flavor, so I was hoping Mayfield could make up for their mediocre creations I’d tried in the past with this one.


As is often the case with premium options, Mayfield is able to keep the calorie content of their Blueberry Cream Pie fairly low at just 150 calories per serving. Remembering back on my experience with the base ice creams in my other Mayfield cartons, I was a bit skeptical coming into this one considering they were using a cream cheese base. My first bite was comprised solely of the base, and to my surprise, was much better than I had expected. Mayfield has allowed the unique flavor of cream cheese to shine through the sugar and take center stage. This time around, the consistency even seemed to be just dense enough to allow all the flavors come to fruition.


To assist their cream cheese base, Mayfield also included thick stripes of a jam-like blueberry swirl that adds a textural difference as well as a sweet, yet slightly tart addition of flavors. To finish this off, they also included small pieces of what they referred to as sugar pie and what they show as graham crackers in the illustration. What you get in the actual carton looks a bit different, but still serves the same purpose. These bits of pie crust are soft, flaky and give some additional authenticity to a flavor I probably would have still enjoyed otherwise. With a super-premium, cream cheese base, a thicker swirl of blueberry sauce and larger, less uniform bits of pie crust, this could have easily obtained an A.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: B


It just so happened that I had stopped in at Dunkin’ Donuts the same morning and had a few of their Blueberry Cake Munchkins left over. These served as the perfect addition to an already successful flavor to really push its performance over the edge.

REVIEW: Mayfield Candy Bar


While my first two experiences with Mayfield ice cream, Snickerdoodle and Birthday Cake, were enjoyable, they hadn't been extraordinary. The lackluster consistency and puny mix-ins left plenty of room for improvement, but the overall taste, in addition to a large sale promotion, was enough to convince me to sample another selection. Their carton of Candy Bar is described as caramel ice cream with a nougat ribbon and caramel & chocolate-coated peanuts. I've found caramel to create a very capable foundation for any flavor, so maybe Candy Bar can beat out it's Mayfield predecessors using this proven method.



At only 160 calories per serving, the beige base transfers easily from the carton to a bowl. The thick nougat ribbon and plentiful coated peanuts are easily visible, but I grab just the caramel ice cream to begin. The consistency of the previous Mayfield flavors I'd sampled had been somewhat disappointing and this was no different unfortunately. The near-weightless ice cream melted down quickly and had an odd, crumbly texture. Although the consistency wasn't improved upon in this flavor, the taste was certainly an upgrade over my prior experiences. Candy Bar suffered from the same mediocre feel as the others, but was slightly saved by it's caramel flavoring. The base begins mild and slowly faded into a sweet, buttery caramel flavor as the light ice cream broke down.


The sticky nougat swirl becomes thick at points and clings to the ice cream as I remove it with my spoon. Rather than impersonating nougat as the title claims, this came off as a simple enhancement of the base ice cream with a strong taste of caramel, nothing like the same swirl found in Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Nougat Crunch. Candy Bar is finished off with a large amount of chocolate and caramel coated peanuts. The coating on the outside of these chips off upon first contact, allowing the peanut and candy to be broken down separately, but ultimately achieving the same result. The fudge and buttery outer shells leave a rich aftertaste behind each bite they're a part of. Using the same concept that makes up many of our favorite candy bars, Mayfield tried to cash in on the same idea. It's hard to mess up when using ingredients such as caramel, nougat, chocolate and peanuts, but there are better candy-based offerings available than Mayfield's mild-mannered option.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: F