Showing posts with label Meringue. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Meringue. Show all posts
REVIEW: JC's Key Lime Pie Pops
The trend that first started with small, scale artisan brands of prepackaged pints of ice cream and frozen yogurts making their way into organic supermarkets has now evolved into frozen treats of all kinds. One of the products that recently caught our eye was a brand of ice cream bars called JC's Pie Pops. Initially passing on flavors like Apple Pie Crumble and Strawberry Cream, we opted for the Key Lime kind: tangy key lime cream covered in a crunchy meringue, key lime and graham cracker crust. Each box contains two pops and contain 280 calories of all-natural ingredients.
After removing the hockey-puck sized ice cream pop from its packaging, we dove right in with a bite including all the different components. The key lime ice cream was smooth, mild as far as tartness goes, and incorporated just enough key lime flavoring to help assist the crunchy coating. If you look closely, you can easily identify the three separate types; each of which made their way into every bite. When combined with the key lime base, the result was rather effective in impersonating a frozen key lime pie. We've tried quite a few similarly themed products and this was as good as any we've had.
Where I Found It: The Fresh Market
Grade: A
REVIEW: Ben & Jerry's Key Lime Pie (Limited Batch)
With the summer heat in full swing, Ben & Jerry's has decided to release their Key Lime Pie flavor as a limited batch for the next few months. A few of my fellow ice cream enthusiasts had tipped me off that this pie was making a comeback a few weeks before Ben & Jerry's had even released any information on the subject. After many failed attempts at tracking down this South Florida treat, I was finally about to procure a pint at my local Publix Supermarket. Key Lime Pie based ice creams seem to continuously come up short, so I was hoping Vermont's Finest could do better than the competition.
Described as a lime ice cream with a tangy lime twist, fluffy meringue swirl and pie crust pieces, I'm delighted to see that they've included actual pieces of pie crust in this one. All the other components will be attending their coming out party to my palate. I hadn't heard much feedback as far as other reviews were concerned, but after this dreamy description I'm ready to dig right in. After removing the top to this limited batch, the first layer of this 270 calories per serving, super-premium ice cream seems pretty pedestrian. As I pulled my spoon across the top layer, I can't seem to find nearly as much going on beneath the surface as I had initially expected, but hopefully the taste can make up for the lack of looks.
Following my first few bites, I've determined why Ben & Jerry's is usually able to pull off these fruit-based flavors better than the competition. They tend to teeter towards a sweet vanilla taste rather than the fruit itself. They allow hints of the true fruit flavor to come through without attacking you with too much, which works especially well with Key Lime, where tartness can be a problem. While true Key Lime lovers may object, I would choose this version of lime ice cream over many of those from other manufacturers. Considering this lacked most of the much-loved tartness of the lime, Ben & Jerry's administers an interesting approach of incorporating some twang in their ice cream. They've thrown in these little stripes of tangy lime twist. They come into play every fourth bite or so and add some serious zest to the equation.
I enjoyed this much more than those who actually try to include the zip of the Key Lime throughout the whole ice cream. The meringue swirl is also a nice supplement. It retains an authentic, light and fluffy feel and invites some sugar inside any bite in which it's involved. Noticeably sweeter than the rest of the ice cream, even when you can't see the meringue inside a bite, you certainly pick up the taste. As much as I enjoyed the swirl of sweetened egg-whites, they can't overpower the pieces of pie crust. These are included in large amounts and even though they're flaky and soft, they're able to be extracted in one big piece.
While it may sound like I loved this newest addition to the Ben & Jerry's lineup, it just wasn't as wonderful as I had hoped. With that said, I've come to the determination that Key Lime Pie is one of those flavor profiles that is best served in it's traditional form. Because of the bountiful amount of mix-ins, my mouth was never bored, but it can't overcome the fact that this is one of those desserts that has trouble being successful when transformed into an ice cream. There's something about tangy fruits that imposes a ceiling. They'll never be as comforting as their chocolate, vanilla and peanut butter brethren. I can't imagine a Key Lime flavor being much better than this and it still wasn't enough to avoid an average rating.
Where I Found It: Publix Super Markets
Grade: C
REVIEW: Dairy Queen Lemon Meringue Pie Blizzard (July 2013 Blizzard of the Month)
It’s very rare that I have the opportunity to pick up Dairy Queen’s Blizzard of the Month on the day that it’s released, but this happened to be one of those occasions. After going extra hard in the gym earlier today, I stopped by the drive-thru to try out July’s limited edition flavor, Lemon Meringue Pie. Lemon based desserts are something I’ve only recently took a liking to and the new combination of lemon meringue pie filling, crunchy pie pieces and whipped topping in creamy vanilla soft serve sounded like the perfect way to reward myself. Not knowing how much I’d enjoy this Citrusy Surprise, I opted for the small size instead of the medium I usually go for. I ordered, paid my $3.39 and then waited for two or three minutes while the cashier blended up my Blizzard.
Similar to the Banana Cream Pie Blizzard I went with a few weeks ago, the Lemon Meringue Pie Blizzard comes topped with a mound of whipped cream that billows up and out of the small cup. As I pulled out the red spoon, a large collection of soft serve, pie pieces and yellow flecks came with it. Dairy Queen’s signature soft serve has been infused with the same lemonade concentrate as they use to make their Lemonade Chiller and, unlike some other lemon based desserts, allows the sour characteristics of the citrus to shine through. Although I may not have been a fan of this tart flavoring a few months ago, my feelings were all in favor now.
I’m not quite sure what the meringue pie filling looked like before it was added to this Blizzard, but it gets a bit lost in the soft serve after being mixed. To make up for this, they’ve added in plenty of pie crust pieces; almost enough to get at least one in every bite. These chunks of crust add some crunch, authentic flavor and the pieces that were hit by the blender give the whole Blizzard a gritty, granulated feel. When the whipped cream is shoved down into the soft serve with the other ingredients, the taste is pretty similar to what you’d find in a real lemon meringue pie; without the fluffy texture of the meringue of course. Granted this couldn’t keep contend with powerhouses like last month's S’mores Blizzard (still available by the way), if you’re a fan of lemon ice creams, July’s Blizzard of the Month might be for you.
Where I Found It: Dairy Queen
Grade: C
REVIEW: New Orleans Ice Cream Co. Baked Alaska
With the exception of Mardi Gras Pie, which New Orleans Ice Cream Company has kept under wraps up to this point, I had only one remaining pint left to review in their current lineup. The last and final flavor comes with the following description, “Delight in a decadent dessert of vanilla bean ice cream with crunchy meringue pieces, fresh strawberries, moist cake pieces & a soft meringue swirl.” Considering the success of their other cake-inspired creations such as their Lemon Doberge Cake or Red Velvet Cake, I look forward to finishing my adventure with Baked Alaska.
![]() |
| Credit: Todd Coleman |
As I pulled up on the silver rim, a large gob of the 250 calories per serving, super-premium ice cream clung to the lid even after removal. The ingredients inside are intertwined so tightly that the vanilla bean base has morphed into something completely different. The sweet, fluffy nature of the meringue components have provided their sugary taste and light texture, while the strawberries have added a fruity freshness to the vanilla bean ice cream. This results in an exceptional texture that’s only built upon when the rich, moist cake comes into play. Every mix-in seems to add a different texture and another element of sweetness.
Although I was afraid when I started uncovering the oversized hunks of strawberries, New Orleans Ice Cream Company is able to avoid the horrid feel usually derived from the frozen fruit. Just as they did in their Ponchatoula Strawberry, these add an authentic feel to Baked Alaska. Even one of my least favorite ice cream additions couldn’t hold this flavor back from the A it deserved. As my journey ended, it was hard not to look back over all the unique experiences I spooned my way through. New Orleans Ice Cream Company has created a line of flavors that should make the Crescent City proud. For any of you still on the fence about New Orleans Ice Cream Company, skeptical about ordering ice cream online, or are fortunate enough to live in an area where their flavors are locally available; make it a priority to try them all.
Grade: A



