Showing posts with label Graham Cracker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Graham Cracker. Show all posts
REVIEW: Publix Premium New York Cherry Cheesecake (Limited Edition)
After trying their Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel Sensation a few weeks ago, I was encouraged to further explore the new limited edition offerings from Publix. Themed around a Broadway production, Publix Premium's latest comes in the form of New York Cherry Cheesecake. Although I've had quite a collection of cheesecake creations over my ice cream career, Jeni's Splendid Goat Cheese with Red Cherries was the only one to revolve around the small red fruit. Although I'm not expecting the same quality in this carton, the description of cheesecake-flavored ice cream with a tart cherry ribbon and graham crust pieces keeps me optimistic, especially after popping off the top and taking a peek inside.
In addition, since this only contains 170 calories per serving, it's a lot less calorie dense than it's adversary from Jeni's. Thick enough to resist the edge of my spoon, I finally get a bowl filled with the impressive looking ice cream above. The vivid red stripes of cherry sauce and dark pieces of graham cracker crust look even more enticing when contrasted against the light-colored cheesecake base. Since I'm well versed in the realm of cheesecake-flavored ice cream, and haven't had any from Publix Premium, I'm looking forward to my first experience. The bright white base leads with the familiar taste of cream cheese, but has a nice balance of sweetness on the back end. Although this isn't on the level of Jeni's when it comes to complexity, the mildness should allow the mix-ins to flourish.
The density of the cheesecake ice cream walks the line between the lower-calorie likes of Edy's and Blue Bunny and the premiums like Ben & Jerry's. The cherry swirl seemingly makes it's way into nearly every bite, adding an aesthetically pleasing red-striped design throughout the entire carton. The taste didn't have the bitter tartness of other sour swirls I've seen, but instead acts much like the finishing drizzle of sauce placed on an authentic piece of cheesecake, only adding a slight sweetness and a bit of a texture. The final component, the graham crust pieces, are among the most unique pie crust pieces available. Where most are slightly crunchy and finish with a gritty feel, these share the same consistency as a soft, chewy cookie. So if you're in the mood for Jeni's Goat Cheese with Red Cherries and money is an issue, as well as availability, Publix Premium's product should act as an acceptable substitute.
Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: C
REVIEW: Trader Joe's S'mores Ice Cream Sandwiches
Sometime last month my small, but slowly expanding, hometown of Asheville, NC was graced with the presence of its first Trader Joe's location. I'd been meaning to swing by to pick up few things and browse their ice cream selection, but once I received a recommendation from one of my readers to try out their S'mores frozen sandwiches, I finally made the trip across town. Each box comes with four of these small, circular, individually wrapped sandwiches that Trader Joe's describes as graham crackers with marshmallow-chocolate swirl gelato and milk chocolate flakes.
These come in at 250 calories each, which is pretty consistent with many of the other novelty sandwiches and bars I've had. Unlike a real s'mores, Trader Joe's frozen versions utilize two super-soft, graham cracker cookies that offer little resistance to teeth before breaking through to the gelato stuffed in between. They offer all the taste of a graham cracker, but none of the crunch. The marshmallow-chocolate swirl gelato feels to be on the lighter side and melts down rather quickly. The chocolate is mostly drowned out by the sugary, marshmallow flavoring, but the small chocolate flakes help balance everything back out and provide an accurate frozen representation of the classic s'mores sandwich. While these didn't quite have what it took to earn an A, they were still well above average.
Where I Found It: Trader Joe's
Grade: B
REVIEW: Cold Stone Creamery Pumpkin Pie in the Sky
Cold Stone Creamery is somewhat uncharted territory for our blog. We've tried some of their prepackaged containers, all of which have scored well, but it wasn't until the release of their Fall signature creations that we stopped in to review something freshly prepared. Bypassing the Campfire Classic (marshmallow ice cream with graham cracker pie crust, chocolate shavings and fudge), we went straight for their Pumpkin Pie in the Sky. Bringing together pumpkin ice cream with graham cracker pie crust, whipped topping and caramel, we opted for the "Love It" sized cup (medium). At around 750 calories for the moderate sized portion, this isn't very much bang for your caloric buck and at close to $5.00 with tax, the signature creations aren't light on the wallet either. Unfortunately for us, our ice cream creator even managed to leave out one of the four ingredients we were paying for by stopping a step short of the caramel sauce drizzle seen on the advertisement.
After being pulverized with two large metal spatula looking ice cream scoops for a substantial amount of time, the combination was at the ideal consistency for immediate consumption. With such relentless mixing, the bits of graham cracker had penetrated practically every bit of the pumpkin base. This not only added some graham cracker taste to each bite, but also a terrific texture; a smart strategy considering the mediocrity of their pumpkin ice cream. We've had quite a few different variations from various manufacturers at this point and Cold Stone Creamery's pumpkin base was middle of the road at best. The whipped topping helped round out the pumpkin pie theme, but added little as far as overall performance goes. We'd suggest checking out some of our other top performing pumpkin flavors before heading into a Cold Stone Creamery for your Fall fix.
Where I Found It: Cold Stone Creamery
Grade: B
READER REVIEW: Derek's Review of Good & Delish S'mores Swirl
I finally decided to stop into Walgreens to try Haagen Dazs' Pralines and Cream and a large variety of Delish ice cream caught my eye. Having never heard of the brand before, I was quite intrigued by a few of the offerings. The cream of the crop looked to be the S’mores Swirl, which was described as “marshmallow and chocolate ice cream swirled with dark chocolate chunks and a graham swirl.” Now I’ve never encountered a graham swirl I didn’t like. And if the marshmallow flavor was even half as good as that found in a true s’more I was in for a treat. At 260 calories a serving, I was hoping this unknown brand was comparable to that of its super premium counterparts.
I was put off by the thin layer of ice on top of the pint. There was no seal, which isn’t a necessity, but because the pint wasn’t packed to the brim it allowed for space for ice to gather. Undeterred, I went straight for the chocolate base. The ice had no impact on the consistency of ice cream whatsoever so it was quickly moot point. The chocolate flavor screamed of milk chocolate. It reminds me of that found in Ben and Jerry’s Peanut Butter World, which is one of my favorite bases. To be honest, this is one of the better chocolate bases I have ever had. It’s sweet, creamy, but not overpowering. The marshmallow base on the other hand was something entirely different. It has a fluffier, smoother consistency than the chocolate. It’s almost as if it was composed of 25% straight marshmallow fluff and 75% ice cream. The flavor was slightly artificial, but wow was it ever amazing. In terms of unique base flavors this definitely cracks the elite list. It’s very sweet, maybe even too sweet for some people but it’s perfectly balanced by the chocolate half. For me just a spoonful of the two bases was already enough to make this pint respectable.
The dark chocolate chips were everywhere and added that perfect crunch that is needed in such a creamy concoction. The pieces are slightly larger in size than those found in a lot of other brands and the dark chocolate aspect is definitely the correct choice in this setting. The graham swirl had been screaming at me since the beginning and I couldn’t hold back any longer.
This graham swirl is beyond remarkable. It’s like they took honey graham crackers and a heaping handful of brown sugar and mashed them together. The flavor is intense and the consistency is that of an unbaked, sugar-laded graham cracker crust. I was total unprepared for the flavor bombardment, but just a tiny bit of this swirl combined with the other components created the best recreation of s’mores flavor I have had to date. I was sure nothing could hold this back from being a perfect A. Unfortunately, the graham swirl was slightly lacking for what I would expect to find in a super premium ice cream. It was prominent at the top and the bottom, but as you can see there was very little throughout the middle half of the pint. I’m a recovering mix-in junkie, okay not recovering, so I will admit my bias. Regardless, this is a great pint and worth a try for anyone who wants a flashback to making s’mores around the camp fire.
Where Derek Found It: Walgreens
Derek's Grade: B
REVIEW: Ben & Jerry's Pumpkin Cheesecake (Limited Batch)
This year, even more than others, it seems Americans have become obsessed with the thought of pumpkin. What previously seemed to have only been a phase has turned into an all-out epidemic. Companies across the country have packed pumpkin flavoring into absolutely everything with the hopes of increased revenue. As a part of the craze myself, I've been pretty impressed thus far with the Fall flavor releases. Companies like Graeter's use a simple, pumpkin-puree base, while Turkey Hill takes another approach with a swirl of cinnamon graham cracker to impersonate pie crust. Ben & Jerry's strays from the beaten path completely with their limited batch Pumpkin Cheesecake.
They've been on the pumpkin bandwagon for multiple seasons now and continue to take the cheesecake route, despite carrying a Pumpkin Pie flavor in their scoop shops. To create their version, Ben & Jerry's has blended together their patented graham cracker swirl with a pumpkin cheesecake base ice cream. With the exception of Berry Voluntary, all of their cheesecake flavors have gotten fairly high rankings from me, and with the limited batch stake in the background, this has the potential to catapult towards the top. Lifting off the pumpkin patch imprinted lid exposes a pastel orange base, but no signs of the graham cracker swirl.
Containing 270 calories per serving, this is pretty standard as far as super-premium ice creams are concerned. With the thick consistency, the pumpkin cheesecake base resists, but eventually breaks away enough to gather on the end of my spoon. Ben & Jerry's tends to flip-flop on how full-bodied they allow their cheesecake flavors to be. Berry Voluntary tended to let the fruit take the lead role, while Strawberry Cheesecake allowed the unique taste of cheesecake to take center stage. After taking my first bite, I'm relieved to find this flavor leads with loads of pumpkin.
Going light on the nutmeg, Ben & Jerry's has created one of the nicest pumpkin blends imaginable. When the dense ice cream encounters taste buds, the sweet and spiced flavor of pumpkin come forth, but follows with the taste of smooth, authentic cheesecake. Bite after bite of the pumpkin cheesecake ice cream continues to impress. It isn't long before I hit the patented graham cracker swirl that acts as this cheesecake's crust. The gritty, sugar-soaked swirl adds authentic graham cracker flavor and some much needed texture to the base.
The consistency of the graham cracker swirl used by Ben & Jerry's has quickly evolved into one of my favorites. I've heard complaints of a small amount of the swirl in pints, but mine was packed from top to bottom, enhancing nearly every bite. Unless a super-premium player makes a perfect pumpkin pie flavor, I don't see anything rising above this seasonal selection. The powerful combination of pumpkin, graham cracker crust, and cheesecake result in one of the best flavors of Fall.
Where I Found It: Super Wal-Mart
READER REVIEW: Elliot's Review of Phin & Phebes Coconut Key Lime
A bit of pumpkin overload and some mild carotenemia have me ready for a break from fall flavors. Coconut Key Lime by Phin and Phebes (pronounced Finn and Feebs) is the perfect sub-tropical oasis.
The electric green glow of many key lime pie ice creams and desserts never seem to foretell greatness, and is no substitute for well-balanced key lime flavor. As you see in the photos, Coconut Key Lime does not make that attempt to prove its identity.
This is the best key lime ice cream I've ever tasted. The tangy lime flavor plays nicely with the creamy, coconut tinged base, so there is no confusion about it - this is premium ice cream. This pint avoids the cloyingly sweet, sorbet-like taste characteristic of many other key lime pie ice creams. The incredibly creamy texture of the ice cream is exceptional. The coconut flavor is understated, but makes its presence known. Graham cracker crumbs are spread evenly, in a ladylike fashion. No enormous troves, concentrated clusters or oversized pieces here, nor are there in any Phin and Phebes pint. Consistency and balance are the dominant themes.
To my surprise, this is not one of their best selling flavors. People just need to taste it and that would change. Phin and Phebes take straightforward, natural ingredients and spin them into magic here. Track them down and taste it for yourself.
Where Elliot Found It: Straub's Market
Elliot's Grade: A
READER REVIEW: Ryan's Review of Private Selection New York Style Pumpkin Cheesecake (Seasonal Offering)
It's October and with that said pumpkin products are everywhere.The fall season brings mass amounts of pumpkin joy for everyone even ice cream eaters. Private Selection's pumpkin themed ice cream is described as pumpkin flavored ice cream with dense pieces of cheesecake, how good does that sound? Pretty good to me.
I must say I was excited when I came across Private Selections new seasonal offering. I've been a pretty big fan of basically everything ice cream related from them so this was a confident buy off the bat. This time around I decided to go straight to my silverware drawer after grocery shopping and grab a spoon. First thing I notice upon opening the seal and taking off the lid was undoubtedly the color orange.
It's clear as day this ice cream looks like a pumpkin pie. I take my first scoop and it's rich in pumpkin taste. For me, personally, you have pumpkin spice desserts or flat out pumpkin desserts and this is definitely a pumpkin dessert. The taste was exactly what I was hoping for. This ice cream carries a delicious pumpkin pie filling just richer. After about two scoops I hit a piece of cheesecake.
The cheesecake pieces are exactly as described, extremely dense and rich. It's a great addition and impressively the pieces of cake are really able to stand out due to the authentic cheesecake flavor. This pairing is a great combination and really adds some interesting bites throughout. There is enough cheesecake in the container to land a bit here and there leaving room for the base of the ice cream to hold its own. Without a doubt this was right next to some of the best pumpkin treats I've had this year and certainly will make sure to get one more container before seasons end.
Where Ryan Found It: Foods For Less
Ryan's Grade: A
READER REVIEW: Elliot's Review of New Orleans Ice Cream Co. Mardi Gras Pie
New Orleans Ice Cream Company has a special place in my heart. I spent a few years living in New Orleans, which afforded me the opportunity to explore the local culinary specialties that inspired many of their distinct New Orleans themed flavors. After reading the in-depth reviews here on the ICI, I'd been coveting the Crescent City themed flavors for months before finally splurging and ordering some online.
Score! I was not disappointed. Like a fat kid at a buffet, I happily made my way through a dozen or so flavors with ease. The pint pictured here, Mardi Gras Pie, is my absolute favorite of theirs and one of my favorites overall.
Moon Pie lovers unite. If you haven't had a Moon Pie, you will want to try one after you taste Mardi Gras Pie. The marshmallow base is slow melting, but when it tempers, Katy, bar the gate! Patience is richly rewarded with one of the best flavor and texture experiences you'll find in a pint of ice cream. The marshmallow base and swirl combined with the stracciatella-like chocolate flakes and graham cracker are a perfect marriage. Cheap, lighter Moon Pie branded ice cream sandwiches don't come close to what you'll find here.
I took it upon myself to see what I could do to make this brand available locally, requesting that a local specialty grocer here in St. Louis begin carrying NOIC. Armed with the product request form available on NOIC's website and the love in my heart, I plead my case. The rest is history, and now NOIC is available in a number of these markets here in town, allowing me the privilege of turning friends and neighbors onto this fine brand.
Where Elliot Found It: New Orleans Ice Cream Co.
Elliot's Grade: A
REVIEW: Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie (Limited Edition)
Much like Publix Premium's Pumpkin Pie ice cream, the words limited edition and pumpkin pie were enough to convince me to introduce Turkey Hill to my taste buds. Fans of the blog have tried to talk me into bringing this brand on board for some time now, but now it's official. Fully illustrating what's to come inside, the outside of the carton is decorated with a slice of pie, a pumpkin patch, and a picture of the ice cream itself. At 170 calories per serving this seems to be a lighter option, much along the lines of Blue Bunny and other generic brands I've tried over the past few months.
While Publix Premium's Pumpkin Pie incorporated a whipped cream ribbon and pie crust pieces in their pumpkin pie flavored ice cream, Turkey Hill says the limited edition lid is hiding pumpkin ice cream with a cinnamon graham cracker swirl underneath. After removing the top, the base ice cream is a beautiful beige color with a darker patch of the swirl sneaking through to the top. The tiny tidbit of the graham cracker poking through the surface gave no inclination as to exactly how much was hiding underneath.
As I began to scoop some out into a bowl, the cinnamon graham cracker swirl was so concentrated that it had created a marble design against the pumpkin ice cream. I've always enjoyed the graham cracker swirls in a variety of flavors from Ben & Jerry's, but after seeing the amount inside Turkey Hill's Pumpkin Pie, this could easily surpass the competition. I collect some of the pumpkin ice cream on my spoon and take a sample. The first thing I notice is the consistency. Much like Blue Bell, the feel of Turkey Hill's ice cream is light and fluffy, but lacks the hated gummy texture that many non-super premium brands tend to have.
It's hard to concentrate on the consistency for too long, however, because my taste buds are instantly bombarded with pumpkin flavor. Strong notes of cinnamon and sugar combine with the pumpkin ice cream to create an overall taste that comes pretty close to that of actual pumpkin pie filling. This smooth base should be more than adequate to showcase these thick stripes of cinnamon graham cracker swirl. After a few bites of the base, I attack the ribbons with my spoon. Because of the firm, thick texture of the graham crackers, it takes some serious effort to break them apart. Loading my spoon up with a pile of pumpkin ice cream and the cinnamon swirl, I try the flavor the way Turkey Hill intended.
The dark color only gives slight hints of the strong cinnamon explosion to come. Packed firmly inside the ice cream, this swirl tastes nearly identical to slightly-pliable cinnamon Honey Maid Graham Crackers. Bite after bite of the combination creates a proficient pumpkin pie flavor that left me wanting a second bowl, a desire that I quickly gave in to. This limited edition offering provided a perfect introduction to the brand and secured a rather high ranking for a first impression. I'll be sure to keep a lookout for more of Turkey Hill's limited edition flavors, as well as catching up on some of their classics.
Where I Found It: Kroger
Grade: A
REVIEW: Sam's Review of Dairy Queen's Pumpkin Pie Blizzard
Here's another review from a lucky recipient of our Dairy Queen Free Blizzard Giveaway:
I chose the pumpkin pie blizzard and was pleasantly surprised. As a summer baby, I love the hot weather and with fall approaching I have a lot of mixed feeling. The Pumpkin Pie Blizzard is the perfect transition into fall. I'm all about texture and prominent favors. This blizzard had both, the graham cracker pieces added just the right amount of crunch and the pumpkin flavor was both prominent but balanced. I was completely satisfied by the end. The service at our local DQ was also pleasant. Overall great experience!
Where Sam Found It: Dairy Queen
Grade: A
READER REVIEW: Emily's Review of Dairy Queen's Pumpkin Pie Blizzard
Ever since I saw Dairy Queen’s Blizzard Battle advertised for the month of September, I have been craving both the Pumpkin Pie Blizzard as well as the Apple Pie Blizzard but have always ended up fulfilling my ice cream fix at the local Handel’s instead. However, when The Ice Cream Informant offered a coupon to try either blizzard, I could not turn down the incentive. As a big blizzard fan and a raging chocoholic, ordering something other than the Chocolate Extreme or Heath with added brownie seemed unfamiliar. Yet, with my coupon in hand, I settled on the Pumpkin Pie blizzard based on the rave reviews circulating since last year.
My local Dairy Queen seems to often skimp on the toppings yet, to my excitement, this blizzard was different. Making my way through the tall layer of nutmeg-dusted whipped cream that topped the cup, I was pleased to find my spoon-full loaded with bits of piecrust. The crust added just the right crunch to perfectly compliment the soft-serve generously loaded with pumpkin puree. The overall flavor of the soft-serve was had a pleasant pumpkin overtone but was not overdone. The nutmeg spices seemed to tie everything together, creating an authentic pumpkin pie experience in ice cream form. While I thoroughly enjoyed the Pumpkin Pie Blizzard, in my opinion it still falls far short of the S’mores blizzard from the summer. That being said, I would still give this blizzard a B rating.
Where Emily Found It: Dairy Queen
Emily's Grade: B
My local Dairy Queen seems to often skimp on the toppings yet, to my excitement, this blizzard was different. Making my way through the tall layer of nutmeg-dusted whipped cream that topped the cup, I was pleased to find my spoon-full loaded with bits of piecrust. The crust added just the right crunch to perfectly compliment the soft-serve generously loaded with pumpkin puree. The overall flavor of the soft-serve was had a pleasant pumpkin overtone but was not overdone. The nutmeg spices seemed to tie everything together, creating an authentic pumpkin pie experience in ice cream form. While I thoroughly enjoyed the Pumpkin Pie Blizzard, in my opinion it still falls far short of the S’mores blizzard from the summer. That being said, I would still give this blizzard a B rating.
Where Emily Found It: Dairy Queen
Emily's Grade: B
REVIEW: Blue Bell Blueberry Cheesecake
At the end of August, not only did Blue Bell release the new Chocolate Peanut Butter flavor, but they also brought back a flavor that hasn’t been around in a while. Their Blueberry Cheesecake is made up of a rich, cheesecake ice cream loaded with cheesecake pieces and a flavorful blueberry sauce swirl. Blue Bell’s Strawberry Cheesecake, which I tried almost a year ago to the day, had been one of my favorite cheesecake-inspired flavors and one of the few to include actual bites of cheesecake, so naturally I was excited to finally see the Blueberry version show up on shelves. Even though I had to invest in an entire half-gallon carton, I was confident that I would have no issue polishing off the whole thing in due time.
Most cheesecake based flavors tend to be on the heavy side when it comes to the nutrition facts, but Blue Bell has managed to keep this particular combination to a reasonable 170 calories per serving. With the gold lid removed, I had forgotten how appealing the color of Blue Bell’s rich, cheesecake ice cream had been. If the bright beige base hadn’t been enough eye candy, my particular container had vivid stripes of blueberry sitting right under the surface. One pull across the top layer with my ice cream scoop was all it took for the visuals to really elevate. My first bite of the rich, cheesecake ice cream was just as delicious as I had remembered. Unlike some others, Blue Bell is able to find the ideal balance between tangy and sweet for their base.
Where their Strawberry Cheesecake featured actual strawberries and a strawberry sauce, this Blueberry counterpart is much better, and without actual frozen fruit, performs better too. The flavorful swirl may look purple, but it brings a ton of sweet, blueberry taste to the equation. The finishing touch comes from the actual squares of cheesecake scattered about. These chunks feature a rich, tangy cheesecake filling dusted with graham cracker that goes great with the other ingredients; all while bringing an authentic feel to this flavor. Even though I’m biased towards any flavors using cheesecake, I found Blue Bell's Blueberry version to be one of the best I’ve ever had. This also raises the question, with Fall right around the corner, why not release a Pumpkin Cheesecake?
Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: A








.jpg)











