.

Showing posts with label Cheesecake. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cheesecake. Show all posts

REVIEW: Publix Premium New York Cherry Cheesecake (Limited Edition)


After trying their Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel Sensation a few weeks ago, I was encouraged to further explore the new limited edition offerings from Publix. Themed around a Broadway production, Publix Premium's latest comes in the form of New York Cherry Cheesecake. Although I've had quite a collection of cheesecake creations over my ice cream career, Jeni's Splendid Goat Cheese with Red Cherries was the only one to revolve around the small red fruit. Although I'm not expecting the same quality in this carton, the description of cheesecake-flavored ice cream with a tart cherry ribbon and graham crust pieces keeps me optimistic, especially after popping off the top and taking a peek inside.


In addition, since this only contains 170 calories per serving, it's a lot less calorie dense than it's adversary from Jeni's. Thick enough to resist the edge of my spoon, I finally get a bowl filled with the impressive looking ice cream above. The vivid red stripes of cherry sauce and dark pieces of graham cracker crust look even more enticing when contrasted against the light-colored cheesecake base. Since I'm well versed in the realm of cheesecake-flavored ice cream, and haven't had any from Publix Premium, I'm looking forward to my first experience. The bright white base leads with the familiar taste of cream cheese, but has a nice balance of sweetness on the back end. Although this isn't on the level of Jeni's when it comes to complexity, the mildness should allow the mix-ins to flourish.


The density of the cheesecake ice cream walks the line between the lower-calorie likes of Edy's and Blue Bunny and the premiums like Ben & Jerry's. The cherry swirl seemingly makes it's way into nearly every bite, adding an aesthetically pleasing red-striped design throughout the entire carton. The taste didn't have the bitter tartness of other sour swirls I've seen, but instead acts much like the finishing drizzle of sauce placed on an authentic piece of cheesecake, only adding a slight sweetness and a bit of a texture. The final component, the graham crust pieces, are among the most unique pie crust pieces available. Where most are slightly crunchy and finish with a gritty feel, these share the same consistency as a soft, chewy cookie. So if you're in the mood for Jeni's Goat Cheese with Red Cherries and money is an issue, as well as availability, Publix Premium's product should act as an acceptable substitute.


Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: C

READER REVIEW: Dave's Review of Ben & Jerry's Cheesecake Brownie


After staring at the freezer section for the better part of a few minutes trying to figure out whether I wanted to dive into Candy Bar Pie for the third week in a row, or try the new Peanut Butter Brownie Sundae, or pick up another Pumpkin Cheesecake...I realized I was craving just that, cheesecake. Low and behold, this flavor caught my eye. Under normal circumstances, I'd pick up one of the much more...I guess I should say "American" Ben & Jerry's pints, anything with peanut butter and 14 different kinds of mix-ins. With the craving of cheesecake on mind, I threw this one in the cart.


Sorry for the first shot! I got curious and went for a spoonful shortly after coming back from the store.


First impressions were nothing but positive. I bit into the base, and oh wow, this reminds me of cheesecake immediately. It's a kind of sweet cheesecake, like you'd get from the Cheesecake Factory, not your Italian Grandmother's or a slice from the local bakery. If you've ever had a cheesecake brownie (like pictured on the pint) it tastes EXACTLY like the cream cheese icing on top. While it is very sweet, the cream and texture of cheese is on point. It melts and sticks to your mouth much more so than any of their other ice creams, save for a peanut swirl. If I had to compare it to another brand, it reminds me of Jeni's sweet cream base in how long it sticks to your tongue.


Now, for the downfall. The brownies. I agree with the ICI review in that their not substantial enough. I'm really glad I had a craving for cheesecake, because I would've been disappointed entirely. I go for Ben and Jerry's *for* the mix-ins, and these small brownies thrown in just seemed unplanned. They lack a bite or grit, so the pint is similar to a classic vanilla or chocolate in texture. The brownies themselves aren't chocolatey enough, and they're too small and too far in between. If they were doubled in quantity, or they chose to use the brownies from Chocolate Fudge Brownie, you'd get the full effect. I think what'd really make this flavor shine is the addition of crust pieces or a fudge swirl even instead of the brownies. They need to just go back and tweak this flavor a bit. That being said, this has excellent potential, and the pint itself surely satisfied a craving. I just couldn't help but feel it needed *something* added, like when you're trying to figure out whether or not to throw the kitchen sink or more salt into a big pot of soup. On second scooping, I added some banana chips for a texture element, and man am I sad I didn't the first time around.

Where Dave Found It: Walmart
Dave's Grade: B

REVIEW: Private Selection Maine Blueberry Cheesecake


Ben & Jerry's Blueberry Cheesecake had been my first cheesecake ice cream experience and I still have a hankering for the exclusive flavor from time to time so I was excited to see Private Selection had rolled out this new offering, Maine Blueberry Cheesecake. Described as flaky pieces of crust and blueberries folded into blueberry cheesecake ice cream swirled with blueberry sauce, this has a much more impressive sounding ingredient list. The Ben & Jerry's version had utilized separate blueberry and cheesecake base ice creams with their patented graham crackers swirl.


The dark splotch of blueberry sauce in the background above was the only hint at the excitement going on below the surface of the pastel-purple base. Maine Blueberry Cheesecake comes in at 210 calories per serving, but is so loaded with mix-ins that this still seems a small price to pay. As I fill my bowl, the denseness of the flavors from Private Selection are the ideal combination of fluffy, but still substantial. I can hardly concentrate on the consistency with the flowing rivers of blueberry sauce and sizable pieces of pie crust that I continue to uncover.


Looking at my bowl full of Maine Blueberry Cheesecake, this is one of the most impressive looking ice creams I've come across. The swirl is so incredibly thick that it reminds me of the thick jam included in Jeni's Brambleberry Crisp. The light purple ice cream leads with the taste of slightly tart blueberries, but brings some serious sweetness on the back end in order to balance out the bite of the berries. After a few bites it's evident that Private Selection has erred on the side of caution when it comes to the taste of cheesecake. Seeing as how I usually enjoy ice creams that allow the taste of cheesecake to come through strongly, I was a bit disappointed to find this aspect nearly non-existant.


Fortunately, as the ice cream broke down in my mouth, the consistency was strikingly similar to that of authentic cheesecake. This blueberry cheesecake base also leaves some of the skins behind to add texture. Much like they did with their Southern Recipe Banana Cream Pie flavor, they throw caution to the wind when it comes to their swirls. The blueberry sauce brings with it an intense blueberry tartness, as well as an amazing textural aspect. Despite being surrounded by frozen ice cream, the swirl is able to remain in a slightly liquid-like state. When a large helping of the sauce is combined with the blueberry cheesecake ice cream, it borders on being too tart, so hopefully the pie crust pieces can add some sweetness, as well as texture.


Similarly shaped to the cheesecake chunks in Blue Bell's Strawberry Cheesecake, these simple slivers of pie crust aren't quite as impressive in the taste department. Private Selection attempts to make up for the lack of cheesecake taste in the base ice cream by including an authentic crust. These were soft and flaky, but didn't add much as far as flavor is concerned. Although it was a valiant effort, even the impressive mix-ins couldn't bring this above this blog's standards. I'd stick to Blue Bell or Ben & Jerry's when looking for a blueberry cheesecake fix.


Where I Found It: Kroger
Grade: D

READER REVIEW: Arjun's Review of Ben & Jerry's Cheesecake Brownie

I have not seen this flavor reviewed (by a reader) on this site and rare is the Ben & Jerry’s pint that has not received considerable scrutiny, so I am excited to review this.


The brownies are glorious and the best part is that they are abundant. The further the spoon digs in, the more you are rewarded for your persistence in the form of abundant brownies, to the point of one per spoon full. You can even negotiate multiple brownie pieces per spoon if so desired and the best part is that they are not compromised into smaller pieces. They maintain their beautiful large sizes from the top to the nadir. Throughout the pint, rare is the spoon that does not accumulate an enjoyable ration of brownie to cheesecake ice cream. As you can glean from the pictures, pulling back the lid and witnessing the promise of brownies floating on the surface induced high expectations for this flavor.

There is nothing distinctive about the ice cream base per se. I cannot recall having another flavor with this kind of base, so I am not sure how to compare it. I would be interested to know how it stacks up against Red Velvet Cake. The off white color conveys its uniqueness and each bite delivers as the brownies provide perfect chewy complement to this already delectable base.

Usually in flavors that rely on the simplicity of base plus one mix-in, there is a clamor for addition mix-ins or an accompanying swirl to enhance the experience. No such accouterments are necessary in this flavor. Additions would be overkill at this point. The sheer abundance of the brownie mix-ins are sufficient to garner a top-notch flavor with the unique base. Black and white is the theme to this batch and that lack of complexity is actually a strength.


Every bite of this pint was delightful. I wish that the flavor was made more available; I have not found it any grocery retailer or convenience store. If you find this at a store or make a trip to a scoop shop, I highly recommend this.

On a side bar, I am not sure if the brownie pieces come from the Greyston Factory in Upstate New York that the Informant has written about recently and are featured in classics like Chocolate Fudge Brownie. I was looking for information on the container, but I did not find anything highlighting their association with Greyston. If you read the Chocolate Fudge Brownie paragraph, you will see that company emphasizing that relationship.


Where Arjun Found It: Ben & Jerry’s Scoop Shop (Pre-Packed Pint)
Arjun's Grade: A

REVIEW: Ben & Jerry's Pumpkin Cheesecake (Limited Batch)


This year, even more than others, it seems Americans have become obsessed with the thought of pumpkin. What previously seemed to have only been a phase has turned into an all-out epidemic. Companies across the country have packed pumpkin flavoring into absolutely everything with the hopes of increased revenue. As a part of the craze myself, I've been pretty impressed thus far with the Fall flavor releases. Companies like Graeter's use a simple, pumpkin-puree base, while Turkey Hill takes another approach with a swirl of cinnamon graham cracker to impersonate pie crust. Ben & Jerry's strays from the beaten path completely with their limited batch Pumpkin Cheesecake.


They've been on the pumpkin bandwagon for multiple seasons now and continue to take the cheesecake route, despite carrying a Pumpkin Pie flavor in their scoop shops. To create their version, Ben & Jerry's has blended together their patented graham cracker swirl with a pumpkin cheesecake base ice cream. With the exception of Berry Voluntary, all of their cheesecake flavors have gotten fairly high rankings from me, and with the limited batch stake in the background, this has the potential to catapult towards the top. Lifting off the pumpkin patch imprinted lid exposes a pastel orange base, but no signs of the graham cracker swirl.


Containing 270 calories per serving, this is pretty standard as far as super-premium ice creams are concerned. With the thick consistency, the pumpkin cheesecake base resists, but eventually breaks away enough to gather on the end of my spoon. Ben & Jerry's tends to flip-flop on how full-bodied they allow their cheesecake flavors to be. Berry Voluntary tended to let the fruit take the lead role, while Strawberry Cheesecake allowed the unique taste of cheesecake to take center stage. After taking my first bite, I'm relieved to find this flavor leads with loads of pumpkin.


Going light on the nutmeg, Ben & Jerry's has created one of the nicest pumpkin blends imaginable. When the dense ice cream encounters taste buds, the sweet and spiced flavor of pumpkin come forth, but follows with the taste of smooth, authentic cheesecake. Bite after bite of the pumpkin cheesecake ice cream continues to impress. It isn't long before I hit the patented graham cracker swirl that acts as this cheesecake's crust. The gritty, sugar-soaked swirl adds authentic graham cracker flavor and some much needed texture to the base.


The consistency of the graham cracker swirl used by Ben & Jerry's has quickly evolved into one of my favorites. I've heard complaints of a small amount of the swirl in pints, but mine was packed from top to bottom, enhancing nearly every bite. Unless a super-premium player makes a perfect pumpkin pie flavor, I don't see anything rising above this seasonal selection. The powerful combination of pumpkin, graham cracker crust, and cheesecake result in one of the best flavors of Fall.


Where I Found It: Super Wal-Mart

READER REVIEW: Ryan's Review of Private Selection New York Style Pumpkin Cheesecake (Seasonal Offering)

It's October and with that said pumpkin products are everywhere.The fall season brings mass amounts of pumpkin joy for everyone even ice cream eaters. Private Selection's pumpkin themed ice cream is described as pumpkin flavored ice cream with dense pieces of cheesecake, how good does that sound? Pretty good to me.


I must say I was excited when I came across Private Selections new seasonal offering. I've been a pretty big fan of basically everything ice cream related from them so this was a confident buy off the bat. This time around I decided to go straight to my silverware drawer after grocery shopping and grab a spoon. First thing I notice upon opening the seal and taking off the lid was undoubtedly the color orange.


It's clear as day this ice cream looks like a pumpkin pie. I take my first scoop and it's rich in pumpkin taste. For me, personally, you have pumpkin spice desserts or flat out pumpkin desserts and this is definitely a pumpkin dessert. The taste was exactly what I was hoping for. This ice cream carries a delicious pumpkin pie filling just richer. After about two scoops I hit a piece of cheesecake.


The cheesecake pieces are exactly as described, extremely dense and rich. It's a great addition and impressively the pieces of cake are really able to stand out due to the authentic cheesecake flavor. This pairing is a great combination and really adds some interesting bites throughout. There is enough cheesecake in the container to land a bit here and there leaving room for the base of the ice cream to hold its own. Without a doubt this was right next to some of the best pumpkin treats I've had this year and certainly will make sure to get one more container before seasons end.

Where Ryan Found It: Foods For Less
Ryan's Grade: A

READER REVIEW: Steve's Review of Blue Bell Blueberry Cheesecake

The second half of my Saturday ice cream ritual is a half-gallon of Blue Bell in the evening. This weekend it was Blueberry Cheesecake.

Having had mixed experiences with Blue Bell's fruity cheesecake flavors (Cherry is excellent, but Strawberry was a big disappointment) I didn't have any particular expectations about how I'd like this flavor. Peeling off the top, my mouth began to water as I observed the thick ribbon of blueberry and the off-white color that is the tell-tale sign of Blue Bell's cheesecake flavored ice cream base, which I have always enjoyed.


To my delight, Blueberry Cheesecake has all of the elements that caused me to enjoy Cherry Cheesecake so much: (1) A thick, almost jam-like ribbon of blueberry that wrapped its way generously throughout the container, (b) a creamy base ice cream that tastes quite a bit like real cheesecake, and (c) best of all, an abundant supply of chunks of what tasted like real cheesecake! What's more, these chunks came in different varieties. Some of them are pure cheesecake filling, while others are a combination of this filling with what appeared to be and tasted like crumbly graham-cracker crust. So the chunks themselves offered different, but always delicious, flavor experiences.


The overall effect was quite impressive, as a typical bite included a swirl of blueberry, a chunk of cheesecake, all embedded within the tasty cheesecake flavored ice cream base. And importantly, Blueberry Cheesecake lacked the thing that, in my opinion, almost ruins Blue Bell's Strawberry Cheesecake flavor: It did not have any chunks of frozen fruit. The blueberry presence took the form of the ribbon-swirl only. And you get all this for an astonishingly low 170 calories per serving!


Where Steve Found It: Target
Steve's Grade: B

REVIEW: Blue Bell Blueberry Cheesecake


At the end of August, not only did Blue Bell release the new Chocolate Peanut Butter flavor, but they also brought back a flavor that hasn’t been around in a while. Their Blueberry Cheesecake is made up of a rich, cheesecake ice cream loaded with cheesecake pieces and a flavorful blueberry sauce swirl. Blue Bell’s Strawberry Cheesecake, which I tried almost a year ago to the day, had been one of my favorite cheesecake-inspired flavors and one of the few to include actual bites of cheesecake, so naturally I was excited to finally see the Blueberry version show up on shelves. Even though I had to invest in an entire half-gallon carton, I was confident that I would have no issue polishing off the whole thing in due time.


Most cheesecake based flavors tend to be on the heavy side when it comes to the nutrition facts, but Blue Bell has managed to keep this particular combination to a reasonable 170 calories per serving. With the gold lid removed, I had forgotten how appealing the color of Blue Bell’s rich, cheesecake ice cream had been. If the bright beige base hadn’t been enough eye candy, my particular container had vivid stripes of blueberry sitting right under the surface. One pull across the top layer with my ice cream scoop was all it took for the visuals to really elevate. My first bite of the rich, cheesecake ice cream was just as delicious as I had remembered. Unlike some others, Blue Bell is able to find the ideal balance between tangy and sweet for their base.


Where their Strawberry Cheesecake featured actual strawberries and a strawberry sauce, this Blueberry counterpart is much better, and without actual frozen fruit, performs better too. The flavorful swirl may look purple, but it brings a ton of sweet, blueberry taste to the equation. The finishing touch comes from the actual squares of cheesecake scattered about. These chunks feature a rich, tangy cheesecake filling dusted with graham cracker that goes great with the other ingredients; all while bringing an authentic feel to this flavor. Even though I’m biased towards any flavors using cheesecake, I found Blue Bell's Blueberry version to be one of the best I’ve ever had. This also raises the question, with Fall right around the corner, why not release a Pumpkin Cheesecake?


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: A

REVIEW: Blue Bell Strawberry Cheesecake


Having fully explored the available cheesecake lineup available from Ben & Jerry's, I was excited when I heard Blue Bell had rolled out Strawberry Cheesecake as one of their Summer rotational flavors. Adorned with a yellow-tag announcing Now with Cheesecake Pieces, this was a no-brainer.


After enjoying Ben & Jerry's Strawberry Cheesecake so much, I would have picked this one up even if there weren't pieces of real cheesecake involved. These added chunks of cheesecake have me hopeful, considering that's the only component all the other cheesecake creations seem to be missing.


Breaking down the description above, not only am I ready to try out these new cheesecake pieces, I'm also anticipating the swirls of delicious strawberry sundae sauce. Lacking any signs of graham cracker swirl, I'm hoping the other ingredients can carry the load. Tearing off the top to this tub, I'm left looking at a lovely layer of ice cream loaded with strawberries and sauce. The hue of the base ice cream is strikingly similar to actual cheesecake.


After spooning out some of the cheesecake base, my first bite wasn't quite up to par with the premium cheesecake bases by Ben & Jerry's, and nowhere close to that of Jeni's Goat Cheese with Red Cherries. Blue Bell erred on the side of sweetness, instead of letting the distinct taste of cheesecake come through, but the strawberry sundae sauce is an excellent addition. I used to love squirting this stuff in a big glass of milk as a kid to make strawberry milk, and I love it being incorporated in this cheesecake ice cream. 


Only a few bites in, I run into the dice-sized chunks of cheesecake. Equipped with a graham cracker crust coating, these bundles of cheesecake bliss are unbelievable. They're dense, chewy, creamy and taste exactly like authentic cheesecake. I just don't understand why other companies haven't utilized this approach. Topping the tremendous trio of cookies in Christmas Cookies in July, this is one of the best mix-ins Blue Bell has to offer. Unfortunately, I come careening back to Earth after encountering my first frozen strawberry slice.


As usual, these fruit pieces hinder this flavor from it's full potential. Luckily there weren't very many. By the end of the bowl, I found myself missing that patented gritty, graham cracker swirl from Ben & Jerry's, but as a whole, I'll still take Blue Bell's final product.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: B

REVIEW: Blue Bunny Strawberry Cheesecake (Limited Edition)


Luckily for me, my local Walmart is usually pretty dependable when it comes to offering up new options from some of the country’s most popular ice cream companies; especially some of the harder to find flavors from Blue Bunny. I’d been able to secure cartons of the limited edition Chocolate Caramel Cashew and White Chocolate Caramel Cluster almost immediately after their release, so when I caught wind of their new Strawberry Cheesecake through a Reader Review, I knew exactly where I should look first. Sure enough, this combination of strawberry ribbon swirled in cheesecake ice cream with a graham crunch was sitting front and center in the Blue Bunny section. Cheesecake-based ice creams constantly rank among my favorite, but it’s not one you see used often by non-super-premium companies and it looks like they had to exclude actual cheesecake pieces when churning up this limited edition batch.


I’d thoroughly enjoyed the super-premium pint of Strawberry Cheesecake from Ben & Jerry’s as well as the highly complicated version from Blue Bell, so I was interested to see how this light, 150-calorie per serving, option could hold up. After breaking the tab and pulling off the easy lock lid, the first layer looks promising with plenty of the graham crunch poking through the top and hints of the strawberry ribbon sitting directly underneath the surface. Despite the decent amount of mix-ins, I’m still able to secure a spoonful of the base free of any distractions. Considering this is from Blue Bunny, I was prepared that this wouldn’t possess a super-premium consistency, but I was surprised at how much I enjoyed the sweet taste of their cheesecake ice cream. Most cheesecake bases are either too tangy or too mild, but this was one of the most well balanced options I’ve tasted.


The stripes of bright red, strawberry ribbon are evenly distributed throughout the entire carton, which ensures that almost every bite includes enough to contribute it’s flavoring. This drizzle of sauce adds another element of sweetness and makes the entire creation uniquely strawberry; my personal favorite cheesecake flavor. The bits of graham crunch are intended to impersonate the thin, graham cracker crust of a cheesecake and considering the low calories involved, serve their purpose. They add much needed texture along with the complimentary taste of graham cracker. While I’m still biased towards their Cookie Creation flavors, Blue Bunny’s limited edition Strawberry Cheesecake wasn’t far behind.


Where I Found It: Super Walmart
Grade: B