Showing posts with label Publix Premium. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Publix Premium. Show all posts
REVIEW: Publix Premium New York Cherry Cheesecake (Limited Edition)
After trying their Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel Sensation a few weeks ago, I was encouraged to further explore the new limited edition offerings from Publix. Themed around a Broadway production, Publix Premium's latest comes in the form of New York Cherry Cheesecake. Although I've had quite a collection of cheesecake creations over my ice cream career, Jeni's Splendid Goat Cheese with Red Cherries was the only one to revolve around the small red fruit. Although I'm not expecting the same quality in this carton, the description of cheesecake-flavored ice cream with a tart cherry ribbon and graham crust pieces keeps me optimistic, especially after popping off the top and taking a peek inside.
In addition, since this only contains 170 calories per serving, it's a lot less calorie dense than it's adversary from Jeni's. Thick enough to resist the edge of my spoon, I finally get a bowl filled with the impressive looking ice cream above. The vivid red stripes of cherry sauce and dark pieces of graham cracker crust look even more enticing when contrasted against the light-colored cheesecake base. Since I'm well versed in the realm of cheesecake-flavored ice cream, and haven't had any from Publix Premium, I'm looking forward to my first experience. The bright white base leads with the familiar taste of cream cheese, but has a nice balance of sweetness on the back end. Although this isn't on the level of Jeni's when it comes to complexity, the mildness should allow the mix-ins to flourish.
The density of the cheesecake ice cream walks the line between the lower-calorie likes of Edy's and Blue Bunny and the premiums like Ben & Jerry's. The cherry swirl seemingly makes it's way into nearly every bite, adding an aesthetically pleasing red-striped design throughout the entire carton. The taste didn't have the bitter tartness of other sour swirls I've seen, but instead acts much like the finishing drizzle of sauce placed on an authentic piece of cheesecake, only adding a slight sweetness and a bit of a texture. The final component, the graham crust pieces, are among the most unique pie crust pieces available. Where most are slightly crunchy and finish with a gritty feel, these share the same consistency as a soft, chewy cookie. So if you're in the mood for Jeni's Goat Cheese with Red Cherries and money is an issue, as well as availability, Publix Premium's product should act as an acceptable substitute.
Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: C
REVIEW: Publix Premium Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel Sensation (Limited Edition)
Before Publix could even phase out their holiday limited edition lineup, new, unannounced options have infiltrated my Publix freezer section. Appearing to rip off the idea from Ben & Jerry's Chubby Hubby flavor, Publix Premium's Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel Sensation follows a very similar recipe. Although they've dumped the malt vanilla base for their own rich chocolate ice cream, they've incorporated the same milk chocolate coated pretzel balls, sans peanut butter filling, as well as peanut butter ripples. Hopefully that'll be enough to offset the creepy joker on the front of the container.
Fortunately for us, where Ben & Jerry's version comes in at 340 calories per serving, this tips the scales at only 220. As I begin to scoop some of the dense chocolate ice cream into a bowl, the abundant pretzel balls and large flowing layers of peanut butter bode well for this flavor's fate. With such an incredible amount of mix-ins, it's difficult do grab the base by itself. When I finally manage to sample some, my first impression of the chocolate base comes from the overall mildness. This chocolate ice cream isn't overly rich or dense, just a nice combination of thickness and flavor to accentuate the accompanying ingredients. The peanut butter ripple makes it's way through every nook and cranny the fudge covered pretzels seem to miss. The stiff swirl was among the densest I've ever seen. So thick in fact, that at some points the layer seems to have been spread with a knife. Although most peanut butter swirls are impressive, this is far superior to the ones found in Breyer's Blasts Peanut Butter & Jelly and Reese's Chocolate.
Although they lack the peanut butter filling of the ones included in Chubby Hubby, these fudge covered pretzels come in at the perfect consistency. After the milk chocolate coating melts away, the soft pretzel provides a crunch that drowns out all other noise, leaving a nice mixture of cocoa and saltiness to finish off the flavor of each bite. When dripping with chocolate ice cream and surrounded by a substantial swirl, this trio outperforms most generics and comes close to knocking off it's big brother from Ben & Jerry's. Especially considering the much lower calorie count, this could certainly serve as a sufficient stand-in when Chubby Hubby isn't readily available and you have a hankering for peanut butter, chocolate and pretzels.
Where I Found It: Publix Super Markets
Grade: A
REVIEW: Publix Premium Deep Dish Apple Pie
After trying Publix Premium's incredible Pumpkin Pie flavor, I continued my exploration through their limited edition holiday lineup. Consisting of six flavors in total, the second half gallon container I decided to sample was their Deep Dish Apple Pie. Publix takes apple-flavored ice cream with apple chunks and sugar rolled pie crust pieces and swirls them together with rich cinnamon and brown sugar sauce. I recently tried a similar sounding selection from Breyer's, Apple Cinnamon Crumble, but with the ingredient rundown inside here, coupled with the fact that this comes from the same pedigree as their Pumpkin Pie, I'm expecting a better experience with this carton.
After discarding the lid showing grandma baking up fresh pie, as well as removing the plastic seal protecting the first layer from freezer burn, the first layer looks tame enough. Since this offering only contains 170 calories per serving, especially considering the ingredients inside, I was a bit worried about the consistency of this base, but my worries were put to bay as I began to scoop some into a bowl. The ice cream wasn't overly resistant, easily gathering on the end of my spoon, all the while showing off the large pieces of sugar rolled pie crust and swirls of brown sugar and cinnamon. The first thing I notice about the apple-flavored base is the intense sweetness. While Breyer's version had a bit of a tart bite to it, this drowns out the majority of the apple flavoring with cinnamon and sugar, but in doing so creates one of the most accurate apple pie bases imaginable.
Soon enough I begin to encounter the dual swirls. Depending on which one lands on my spoon, the notes of cinnamon or sugar are intensely amplified, all while adding a slight bit of texture because of their liquid-like state. The crowning jewel comes in the form of the pie crust pieces, which have been rolled in sugar incase you haven't gotten enough already. The fragments of crust were large, substantial and varied in texture. Some were soft and chewy, some were crunchy, but they were all bursting with cinnamon-sugar flavor. Although this couldn't quite compete with the quality of New Orleans Ice Cream Company's vanilla ice cream or bits of Hubig's Pie, it wasn't far behind, and seems to be much more obtainable.
Where I Found It: Publix Super Markets
Grade: B
REVIEW: Publix Premium Peppermint Stick (Limited Edition)
Almost every time I drop by Publix, they’re offering a two for $7.00 sale on most of their half gallons of Publix Premium ice creams. A deal like that coupled with the fact that I only have access to Publix a few times a month, means I regularly cash in on this offer. On my last trip, in addition to Caramel Mountain Tracks, I also picked up an option that I’d passed on last year. Publix Premium’s limited edition Peppermint Stick takes the unique approach of pair vanilla ice cream with peppermint candy. With the top tossed aside, the first layer was festive in color and only got better as scoops were transferred from the carton to a bowl.
At only 160 calories per serving, this comes in just above some of the lighter peppermint options currently available. The premium base was as could have been expected. Neither the taste nor consistency was that exciting, but served as a suitable start to show off the peppermint to come. Publix opted for a combination of red and green candies to aid the rather ordinary vanilla base. These add a considerable amount of taste and texture to nearly every bite they happen to be a part of. Not only do they add a crunch, they also provide all the familiar sensations associated with eating mint ice cream. The way the vanilla balances out the mint is a nice alternative to the usual methodology of combining peppermint candies with peppermint ice cream, but unfortunately, this underwhelming duo can’t come close to competing with some of the other limited edition options from Publix Premium.
Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: C
REVIEW: Publix Premium Caramel Mountain Tracks (Limited Edition)
As I often do on my business trips into Publix territory, I packed a cooler and some ice in hopes of scoring some of their recently released, limited edition flavors. Sure enough, not only had they rolled out most of their holiday inspired lineup, I was also able to locate a carton I’d been wanting ever since seeing it as part of a reader’s Freezer Find. I’m always pleased by the creativity of some of the limited edition flavors from Publix Premium, but an intricate combination of toffee ice cream with ribbons of caramel and dotted with praline pecans and milk chocolate caramel turtles seems sounds like more than enough to keep my taste buds occupied. The bear careening down the mountain on a snowboard made of toffee and praline pecans also continued the tradition Publix has made of including wacky artwork on their cartons.
Even with an overly complicated ingredient list like the one we have here, Publix is still able to contain their creation to only 180 calories per serving. As soon as my ice cream scooper removed the first layer, I knew I was in for a treat. Flowing swirls of golden caramel, quarter sized milk chocolate caramel turtles, and tons of praline pecans make themselves readily available to be put in my bowl. The component I was most excited to try, the toffee base, was also the most interesting. My first bite wasn’t overly reminiscent of toffee, but instead meandered more towards the taste of marshmallow. Regardless, the result was successful in providing a great start to yet another winner from Publix Premium.
Caramel Mountain Tracks really came alive once the mix-ins came into play. The entire carton featured flowing rivers of caramel that lasted from start to finish. These thick stripes were sweet, buttery and continued inside the caramel turtles. These large candies featured a rich, milk chocolate shell that easily broke away to release even more of the sweet syrup. The finishing touch to this flavor, the praline pecans ended up being my favorite aspect. These sugary nuts provided just the right amount of sweetness and crunch to elevate this flavor to the top tier.
Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: A
READER REVIEW: Mason's Review of Publix Premium Peanut Butter Cup Frozen Yogurt
I traveled to Florida recently, for reasons I shan’t divulge (though I will say they involved a large ship, lots of open ocean and all you can eat buffets) and I had the wonderful opportunity to sample some Publix brand ice creams and frozen yogurts. Since I live near the west coast and my ice cream selections are pretty sparse - you damn east coasters get all the best stuff - I had to get my fill of Florida ice cream goodness. However, after several days of nonstop, delicious food, I wasn’t in the mood for anything incredibly heavy when I returned. I opted, then, to start my journey with some light albeit delicious, frozen yogurt.
This particular half gallon is Peanut Butter Cup, which happens to be one of my favorite flavors. The description, since I know it’s absolutely tiny in the picture, reads “Peanut Butter Frozen Yogurt with Chocolate-Dunked Peanut Butter Cups”. Sounds fantastic. I ripped open the lid and dove in, because who has the patience for bowls when peanut butter cups are in your imminent future.
The first thing I noticed, surprisingly, was a very prevalent peanut butter flavor. I expected the frozeney yogurt flavor to be front and center, with the peanut butter playing second fiddle, but it really jumped right out at me. Of course, it still tastes like frozen yogurt, but only after a moment or two of resting on your tongue. You can really taste the peanut butter flavor over everything else. Big plus for me.
After a nice sampling of the base, I when for the “Chocolate-Dunked Peanut Butter Cups”, and here was where I was disappointed. Based on the description, I had expected either full cups, a-la Talenti, or large chunks like in Ben and Jerry’s. Alas, it was not to be. The cups were more like slivers. Little shards of peanut buttery goodness that lingered all too fleetingly on the tongue, never quite satisfying. I kept waiting for a large chunk, something substantial to bite into, but I never found one.
To be honest, I really enjoyed this one. It was light and tasty, and really hit the spot. It was by no means a groundbreaking flavor, but it was, for most intents and purposes, exactly what I expected. The addition of large chunks of peanut butter cups would have made this flavor better, but for what it is, it’s not too bad. Considering the Publix house brand is usually on sale (I got two half gallons, this and a limited edition ice cream flavor, for $5.00) and it’s a peanut butter flavor that clocks in at a whopping 130 calories per serving, you could do much, much worse. This one gets a B.
Where Mason Found It: Publix
Mason's Grade: B
REVIEW: Publix Premium Pumpkin Pie (Limited Edition)
With October fast approaching, creameries across the country have wasted no time in churning out their Fall-inspired flavors. I tend to choose a straightforward selection when introducing myself to a new brand, but after my eyes landed on this, there was no way I could opt for anything else. Donning a hearty piece of pie and a dollop of whipped cream, the fact that this was a generic brand made no difference to me. As I went through check out with my half gallon of Publix Premium Pumpkin Pie, the cashier complimented my purchase. She also informed me that the limited edition tagline shouldn't be taken lightly and that I should feel lucky that I was able to capture a carton considering how quickly they sell out.
Prior to this, the only pumpkin-infused flavor I had been able to procure was Pumpkin Cheesecake from Ben & Jerry's, which sold it's main ingredient a little short. Reincarnating one of my all-time favorite desserts in ice cream, Publix describes this as, "Pumpkin Pie flavored ice cream with swirls of whipped cream ribbon and bountiful buttery pie crust pieces throughout." Pulling off the top and tearing off the plastic protective film revealed a pastel-orange first layer with pieces of pie crust poking through the top.
As I overflow my bowl with scoop after scoop, the swirls of whipped cream and buttery pie crust pieces inside the velvety pumpkin pie ice cream have me salivating worse than one of Pavlov's dogs. I load my spoon full and prepare to see how Publix Premium stacks up against the competition. The pale orange ice cream was light and fluffy, lacking the heaviness of other higher calorie options. But for 170 calories per serving, the consistency was above average. The slight gummy texture was still present, but not nearly as bad as some other brands. As soon as this pumpkin pie flavored ice cream hits your tongue it becomes crystal clear what you're eating.
The taste is pretty spot on, bursting with notes of pumpkin pie spices, especially cinnamon and nutmeg. Intertwined with the base ice cream are some thick ribbons of whipped cream. Adding a textural difference, the whipped cream stays light and stringy, as well as bringing some additional sugar to the flavor. Unfortunately, because the pumpkin pie spices are so strong, the swirl just isn't that noticeable unless you're looking for it. Getting off to a solid start, the fate of this ice cream depend on the pie pieces. Utilizing power in numbers, Publix has packed this carton full of sizeable hunks of crust. After my pleasant experience with Private Selection Southern Recipe Banana Cream Pie, I had been on the lookout for more generic flavors employing pie crust and this fits the bill nicely.
These were actually better than I had anticipated. Although they weren't quite as big as the ones from Private Selection, they still had the same great texture. Depending on the bite, the pie crust pieces could be soft and chewy, or crunchy and flaky. The differing textures made each bite a new experience. Everything about this flavor was top-notch for a company that doesn't specialize in ice cream. I would love to see this concept put to use by other, super-premium brands that could execute with more precision. Either way, I'm excited for the bevy of Fall-inspired products to come.
Where I Found It: Publix Super Markets
Grade: C
FREEZER FINDS: New Limited Edition, Seasonal Selections from Publix Premium
Depending on the time of year, Publix Premium always puts out some pretty interesting limited edition flavors. A fellow ice cream follower recently found some of their new options, as well as some proven favorites from past seasons. While I've seen some of the others, the Caramel Mountain Tracks looks brand new.
Here are reviews for three of the four flavors below:
REVIEW: Publix Premium New Orleans Caramel Praline (Limited Edition)
Even though I’ve made it a point to stop by Publix whenever in the vicinity, I still haven’t managed to try the large amount of limited editions they’ve been unrolling. After recent releases like Lemon Sugar Cookie and Upside Down Pineapple Cake both received high marks, I was ready to see if some of the others could live up to the high standards set recently. After passing over options like Black Swamp Raspberry Cheesecake, I noticed another carton of Publix Premium I hadn’t seen before. New Orleans Caramel Praline combines brown-sugar flavored ice cream with swirls of thick caramel and crunchy praline and isn’t the first to focus on the Crescent City candy. What sets this apart from the competition is the same thing that sold me on this selection: the brown-sugar base.
This premium ice cream comes in at a reasonable 180 calories, which is pretty consistent with many of their other mix-in filled offerings. Although they weren’t easily visible from the first layer, as soon as I scraped my scoop across the surface, the thick stripes of golden caramel and single praline pecans revealed themselves. My first bite of the brown-sugar base is sweet as expected, but has a more intricate taste due to the molasses that remains in the sugar. Unlike a simple vanilla, this is more appropriate to mix with the thick caramel that Publix Premium swirled in. This rich, buttery sauce takes the taste of the brown sugar ice cream to the next level by not only enhancing the taste, but also building on the texture.
This flavor is finished with these small, but potent pieces of praline pecans that have been modeled after the world-famous New Orleans versions. These are just hard enough to add a little crunch before they break down and release all the sugar and nutty richness hiding inside. Although there aren’t enough of these to make their way into every single bite, the other components can hold their own when the praline pecans are missing. Like the others, I can’t imagine this half-gallon will last very long in my freezer.
Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: B
REVIEW: Publix Premium Pineapple Upside Down Cake (Limited Edition)
On the way back from my bimonthly out of town business trip, I made my usual stop at Publix to grab another one of their limited edition premium ice cream flavors. After loving Lemon Sugar Cookie last time, I cashed in on a reader recommendation and went with their Pineapple Upside Down Cake: pineapple upside down cake ice cream with swirls of brown sugar pineapple ribbon and upside down cake pieces throughout. Almost every time I drop in, all of their half-gallon cartons have been on sale at 2 cartons for $7.00 and this time was no exception. I even received the $3.50 each sale price even though I only wanted one. This would only be the second time I’d be tasting this particular concept used in ice cream, but the track record of flavors from Publix Premium and reviews I’ve received from readers kept me optimistic.
After pulling off the top and removing the plastic seal from this 170 calorie per serving premium ice cream, the first layer is pale yellow in color and shows off the golden swirls of brown sugar pineapple sauce and upside down cake pieces poking through the top. My initial reaction from the pineapple upside down cake base is that much like their Lemon Sugar Cookie, they utilize only the sweetness from the pineapple. The ice cream starts sweet and subtle, but incorporates a slight bit of cake flavoring on the backend. Even without the tartness, I really enjoyed this. Perhaps my favorite aspect of these new, limited edition flavors from Publix is how they directly include the cake or cookie inspiration right into the base. It’s working well for them and I hope they continue this trend.
It wasn’t long after wrapping my head around the base ice cream that I started to run into the golden swirls of brown sugar pineapple ribbon. This liquid sauce was packed with brown sugar flavor, finishes with the familiar taste of pineapple and really lets the consumer know the inspiration behind this flavor. Coupled with the base, this could have been a pretty capable combination all on its own. Fortunately for us, Publix Premium completes their Pineapple Upside Down Cake Ice Cream with small squares of upside down cake pieces. The chunks are dense, chewy and bring another element of authenticity to the equation. It’s rare that I give a generic carton of ice cream an A, but Publix Premium has been leaving me no choice as of late.
Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: A
REVIEW: Publix Premium Lemon Sugar Cookie (Limited Edition)
A few times a month, my day job requires me to travel out of town. On the return trip I just so happen to pass by a Publix, a supermarket not currently available where I live. With this in mind, I've packed an ice-filled, Styrofoam cooler the past few times I’ve made the trip in order to pick up some usually unobtainable ice cream. Flavors like their Publix Premium Caramel Coast Getaway and Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel Sensation were so surprising that I’ve made it a priority to pick up some of their latest limited editions. About a month ago I received a Freezer Finds submission from a reader that let me know they had released three new flavors. While Black Swamp Raspberry Cheesecake and Pineapple Upside Down Cake sounded enticing, I had my eyes set on Lemon Sugar Cookie: lemon sugar cookie ice cream with lemon sugar cookies and ribbons of vanilla icing. I’ve enjoyed similar flavors such as Blue Bell's Lemon Bliss and Lemon Cookie from Three Twins, so I was hoping this generic option could rival that of the competition.
Publix manages to keep their Lemon Sugar Cookie to only 180 calories per serving, a reasonably low number considering this is a premium ice cream containing cookies. After removing the lid and the protective plastic seal, the first layer is a pale yellow color and shows off plenty of the lemon sugar cookies littered about. Similar to many of the other Publix Premium flavors, this one scoops out easily and lacks the density of a high-butterfat pint of super-premium. Although I prefer the feel of dense ice creams, the flavors involved in Lemon Sugar Cookie are hard to argue with. The lemon sugar cookie base is able to accomplish something I’ve failed to find elsewhere. Instead of the typical tartness associated with citrus ice cream, Publix has somehow incorporated a base bursting with the taste of sugar cookies and only a little amount of lemon.
Publix Premium tends to be hit or miss with the amount of mix-ins they decide to include in their cartons, but they decided to go heavy on their chunks of lemon sugar cookies. These bright yellow bits of crumbly cookie started out crunchy and broke down slowly as I chewed; all the while releasing a more concentrated version of the flavors found in the base ice cream. The ribbons of vanilla icing only enhance the incredible combination of lemon cookies and ice cream. This swirl isn’t easily seen, nor does it add much texture, but bites containing some are the best of the bunch. Publix’s ice cream impersonation of an iced lemon sugar cookie is spot-on and just another reason to continue to pack a cooler on my out of town trips.
Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: A









