.

Showing posts with label Mint. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mint. Show all posts

READER REVIEW: Elliot's Review of McConnell's Peppermint Stick

Candy canes take me down memory lane, a holiday constant going all the way back to the days of my youth. For me, the sight and smell of these fragile, minty, saccharine treats is decidedly associated with Christmastime. It is one of those candies that creates a certain excitement simply based on this seasonal affiliation.


When December rolled around this year, thanks to the local specialty market that stocks McConnell's, I had the chance to scoop McConnell's' Peppermint Stick ice cream. This pint is actually available from McConnell's year round, but only stocked locally during the holidays. Peppermint Stick is an old time flavor from this heritage brand, and that it earns it's spot in the lineup all year long is a very promising sign.


The majority of mint ice creams out there are combined with chocolate, known as "mint chip" on the street. A product of my environment, I have been conditioned to believe the chocolate component is a necessity, and wondered if the mint flavor alone can deliver the goods.


Some issues we've all experienced with candy canes, besides breakage during the unwrapping process, are the cloying sweetness, sticky fingers and potential for dental impact, not to mention the destruction of any finished surface a half eaten cane comes into contact with. Just leave them on the tree this year. This ice cream has a lovely sweet peppermint candy flavor, and the best part is that it plays up the hopelessly thick, high butterfat, low overrun sweet cream McConnell's base I love so much. Some brands may need to throw out a bit of misdirection in the form of other mix ins to shift the focus from a stabilized base lacking structure and flavor balance. If you've got it, flaunt it. McConnell's lets the peppermint accentuate the ice cream, and that is exactly what I love about this flavor.


As you see pictured, candy cane pieces dot the landscape, and provide enough texture to keep things reminiscent of gnashing candy canes through your teeth as a yule log burns warmly in the background. This McConnell's classic is one of the most delicious peppermint ice creams I've ever had. If you're looking for a pint to put you in the Christmas spirit, this is it.


Where Elliot Found It: Straub's Market
Elliot's Grade: A

REVIEW: Graeter's Peppermint Stick (Limited Edition)


Peppermint ice cream seems to be a reoccurring theme on this blog as of late. The holiday season has introduced numerous nominees for review, but considering Graeter's impressive pedigree, I always expect a little more from their French pot process. While I've interrogated an extensive lineup of mint-infused flavors like Edy's Peppermint, as well as fudge-infused gelato like Peppermint Bark from Talenti, none of my prior experiences have come from a super-premium pint like the one above. Sporting a bright red lid and lightly shaded snowflakes, Peppermint Stick joins their Pumpkin and Cinnamon seasonals to round out their limited-edition lineup for 2012.


At 290 calories per serving, this is considerably more dense than any of the other peppermint options I've had, but doesn't stray too far from the nutrition facts of other Graeter's flavors. The lightly colored ice cream is only broken up by the seemingly-melted pieces of peppermint candy that push through the top layer. Considering this is much thicker than the other limited-edition flavors I've had, gathering the pale pink ice cream is nearly impossible until allowed to thaw out for a while. After eventually gathering some of the base and taking my first bite, the consistency is something that just can't be comprehended until you actually try some for yourself. The thick, slow-melting mixture of natural peppermint oil and French pot ice cream has the same cooling sensation of others, but lingers around for much longer. Graeter's manages to balance the sweetness and unique taste and tendencies of mint in a near-perfect fashion.


The area surrounding the peppermint pieces, much like I found in Front Porch's Dandy Peppermint Candy, contains a liquid-like sauce of intense peppermint flavoring that plays perfectly alongside the peppermint ice cream. And because there are so many slivers of peppermint stick, that translates into an ample amount of this neon pink swirl. Once the ice cream and peppermint liquid melt away, they leave behind the last remnants of what used to be an entire peppermint stick. These small slices, which add a slight crunchy texture, effectively rounds out Graeter's rendition of peppermint ice cream. Having tried a handful of ice creams based around the striped candy, it'd be nearly impossible to top Peppermint Stick.


Where I Found It: The Fresh Market
Grade: B

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Lady Liberty Mint


Because of the holiday season, the majority of the mint flavored ice creams I've had recently revolved around the red and white striped candy, but after running across this rarity in my ice cream aisle, I couldn't resist going green. Although I'm not sure of the inspiration behind this particular carton, Turkey Hill pays homage to the Statue of Liberty with Lady Liberty Mint, a mint chocolate ice cream with chocolate cake crunches and crunchy chocolate cookie swirl. Even boasting a slew of statue fun facts on the back of the container, I don't make it through many before skipping straight ahead to tearing the lid off.


After removing the lid dedicated to America's symbol of freedom and democracy, the light green first layer has me yearning for more. Luckily, from prior experience, I've found Turkey Hill doesn't like to show their hand initially. Most of the their cartons containing a swirl tend to concentrate a high quantity into the middle layer, which means most is left to the imagination before breaking ground. The 170 calories per serving is pretty consistent with other Turkey Hill flavors, and is confirmed by the soft, fluffy feel as I scoop some into a bowl. As I had anticipated, the deeper I dug into this carton, the more the enormous crunchy chocolate cookie swirl came into play. Chocolate cookie swirls are among my favorite, and have heavily effected the scores of flavors like Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Therapy, as well as their own Double Dunker.


Bringing my first bite up to my mouth, it's hard to ignore the intense smell of the aromatic herb, more so than with the other mint selections I've recently had. The base ice cream is nice and sweet, containing a strong cooling effect that begins to spread around the inside of my mouth. Although it's not a trait that I appreciate, the smooth, yet fluffy consistency helps alleviate the sensation. As you can see from the pictures, Turkey Hill isn't shy with the amount of chocolate cookies and cake they've shoved inside. The tiny chocolate cake crunchies are almost too small to notice, but the soft pieces of cake inside the slightly crunchy coating add a bit of texture and taste.


Where the French gave America The Statue of Liberty as a gift, Turkey Hill gives us the crunchy chocolate cookie swirl, and to someone who enjoys ice cream, something nearly as valuable. This thick, rich and chocolatey swirl comes in extra-large layers and is just as impressive as the cinnamon, graham cracker swirl found in their Pumpkin Pie. Each mouthful of flaky chocolate cookie that I taste takes me on a trip, with both taste and texture. Although mint flavored ice cream doesn't typically have the ability to truly excel, Turkey Hill has finally found a way to free this ice cream from it's usual ceiling.


Where I Found It: Kroger
Grade: B

REVIEW: Blue Bunny Perfectly Peppermint (Seasonal Limited Edition)


I had been on the lookout for the Seasonal Selection releases from Blue Bunny following a Freezer Find submission last month. I was able to not only secure Spumoni (which we’ll be reviewing later this week), but also Perfectly Peppermint: mint ice cream swirled with peppermint sauce and peppermint candy.


It’s very rare that any food product you actually ingest looks better than the pictures you see in the advertisements or on the packaging, but this is one of those instances. This 160 calorie per serving premium ice cream looked somewhat tame on the surface, but as soon as I started scooping some out, I encountered the most impressive mint swirl we’ve seen.


The mint ice cream base is mild for the most part, providing a sweet, mint foundation to build upon with the other ingredients. The teal and red pieces of peppermint candy added some crunch and additional mint flavoring, but was soon forgotten once I hit the sauce. This bright red concentration of peppermint took the cooling sensation to the next level, and even though it was a bit overpowering, we still gave the trio of ingredients a B.


Where I Found It: Walmart
Grade: B

REVIEW: Haagen Dazs Peppermint Bark (Limited Edition)


After my local Walmart left me empty handed when it came to Ben & Jerry’s latest flavor, Mississippi Mud Pie, they did manage to source another flavor that had been eluding me for some time now. Typically available from October to December, Peppermint Bark from Haagen Dazs is described as rich white chocolate ice cream blended with crunchy chocolate peppermint bark and peppermint candy pieces.


I’d had the pleasure of sampling the white chocolate base from Haagen Dazs before in White Chocolate Raspberry Truffle, so I was excited to see it again in this limited edition. As expected, the white chocolate ice cream is great. It’s smooth, rich and melts down slowly.


From the first layer to the last, there are plenty of mix-ins to make their way into each bite. The crunchy chocolate peppermint bark compliments the white chocolate of the ice cream and first introduces the seasonal taste of peppermint.


The cooling sensation of the mint is intensified when the peppermint candy pieces come into play. These not only add another element of crunch, but really round out the whole peppermint bark effect. While this one is worth picking up for the white chocolate base alone, if you enjoy peppermint bark around the holiday season, this one is worth seeking out.


Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: A

REVIEW: Dairy Queen Candy Cane Chill Blizzard (Blizzard of the Month for December 2013)


As I do at the first of every month, I headed to Dairy Queen to check out the limited edition Blizzard. This month’s Candy Cane Chill variation features peppermint candy cane pieces and choco chunks blended with creamy vanilla soft serve. Since it was only lunchtime, I went with the small sized cup (670 calories). After paying my $3.39, I was a little disappointed that my cup was only about 3/4 of the way full; especially considering how generous my particular location usually is.


The vanilla soft serve and choco chunks are old news when it comes to my previously reviewed Blizzard creations, but the peppermint candy cane pieces put a nice, festive spin on things. The soft, slightly runny peppermint candies give the entire cup a pink hue and both the candies and chocolate provide crunch to each bite. The flavors come together to create a peppermint bark effect. If you’re a peppermint ice cream fan like myself, you’ll want to check this one out before the month is over.


Where I Found It: Dairy Queen
Grade: B

REVIEW: Front Porch Dandy Peppermint Candy


My exploration through the flavors of Front Porch has been a roller coaster ride thus far. I took a small hiatus from the pints that take their inspiration from the Southern lifestyle, but after becoming a peppermint convert when it comes to ice cream, I had to try their Dandy Peppermint Candy. In the past I've tended to avoid peppermint ice cream like the plague, but with the holidays fast approaching and having tried mint flavors from Blue Bell and Edy's, I'm excited to explore this combination of peppermint ice cream with crushed mints.


Using the mentality above, Front Porch approaches their version by taking a bright white base, a shade I haven't encountered yet, and adding crushed green and red striped candies. Removing the top reveals a lightly-colored layer that doesn't effectively hide the colorful candy below. With only 170 calories, this is right in line with the other, non-chocolate mint offerings I've had recently. As my spoon hits the aromatic ice cream, the fluffy yet substantial consistency is reassuring.


My first sample of the base is sweeter than I had anticipated, only allowing subtle hints of the mint to shine through. The typical cooling attribute of peppermint ice cream is kept to a minimum, but that was a positive for my particular palate. The subtleness of the herb allows you to appreciate the deliciousness of mint fused together with sugar and cream. After only my first bite, the crushed candies began showing up on my spoon. I was surprised to find, as I lifted my bite from the pint, that there was a liquid-like swirl surrounding the pieces of peppermint.


Aside from the obvious addition in texture and taste from the actual smashed candy, the gooey swirl left behind enhances this mix-in immensely. The possibly unintentional peppermint swirl is much more effective than just the mint chunks themselves. The unique crunch of the striped peppermint is much better than that found in previous flavors due to the fact that these are just small enough to avoid the painful mistake of chomping down on an overly large piece that isn't quite ready to be chewed. The thick, sweet swirl left behind finishes off this well-constructed creation.


I'm a believer in aesthetics in ice cream to a degree. When a flavor looks delicious, more than likely it will be. The colors left behind by these bleeding pieces of peppermint create a festive looking selection that should certainly be marketed as a holiday-inspired offering, especially seeing as how Dandy Peppermint Candy will be my new go-to pint when I'm craving peppermint.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: C

READER REVIEW: Elliot's Review of New Orleans Ice Cream Co. Mint Chocolate Cookie and Cherries Jubilee

New Orleans Ice Cream Company is a brand that has a special place in my heart. In a world of ice cream where a prevalent trend is to throw around often meaningless, misleading or ambiguous terms like artisan, small batch and from scratch, this company has said from the beginning that they didn't invent ice cream, they are just good at flavoring it and specialize in churning out fun, New Orleans themed flavors.

The ice cream itself is held together with gums that serve as emulsifiers and stabilizers. These ingredients get the job done to hold things together and provide consistency and mouthfeel. This is a common practice in the world of ice cream, even among so many self-proclaimed artisans. There's nothing evil about that approach, it is really a matter of what you get in the end product, your preference and desire for transparency. New Orleans Ice Cream Company relies on this approach and is more apt to highlight the flavors they infuse to create a memorable experience. Personally, if I were able to have the best of both worlds, I'd always choose my platonic ideal ice cream made by an artisan from only milk, cream, eggs and sugar to create a consistent, low overrun, high butterfat base upon which to build a flavor. When there is a specific or unique flavor profile I'd like to enjoy that's not available in a product directly in line with my preference, I may choose a stabilized product.

Let's start with their Mint Chocolate Cookie:


While Mint Chocolate Cookie isn't a New Orleans themed flavor, some of the profits garnered from sales of this flavor are donated to the Make it Right http://makeitright.org/ movement to build homes in communities in need in New Orleans. According to the company, getting the "crackle" / sugary swirl right was a labor of love.


While plenty of sweet, crunchy, well-textured mint chocolate cookies to soak up the spotlight, the sugar "crackle" and mild mint flavored base carries this pint the rest of the way home. This is an altogether enjoyable mint chocolate ice cream, especially if you like your ice cream on the lighter and sweeter end of the spectrum.


This is a great example of how the brand leverages their approach to create a distinctly flavored, consistent product. The stabilizers add durability and some shelf life, and help to keep the mix ins crunchy. The downside with this type of construction is that past a certain point, when you leave this out to temper/soften, the dam breaks and the valley gets flooded, as the ice cream will fall apart.


Elliot's Grade: B


And now on to Cherries Jubilee:


Many of the Crescent City themed flavors from New Orleans Ice Cream Co. have been able to win me over. I've worked my way through most of their catalogue, coming away holding them in high regard. Cherries Jubilee was one of the pints I cared for the least.


Due to it's boozy nature, Cherries Jubilee is a dessert that was too grown up for my taste as a child, and even still. The flavor was lifted from a New Orleans menu and deconstructed into ice cream. This is one of the lighter offerings in the New Orleans Ice Cream Company lineup, and the short ingredient list reveals a reliance upon brandy and orange liqueur for flavor.


The alcohol taste is slightly diminished by letting the flavor temper, allowing the sweetness the cherries provided to carry the flavor a bit. If you're a big fan of the taste element that liquor brings to ice cream, this might be a welcome addition to your ice cream stash.


Elliot's Grade: D

REVIEW: Talenti Peppermint Bark (Holiday Favorite Limited Edition)


Along with my recent infatuation with all things peppermint, it took a seasonal offering to entice me into trying another transparent jar of Talenti. I had fallen in love with Sea Salt Caramel, but had yet to find anything that came close to the one of a kind texture and flavor found inside that selection. Straying from the typical sepia shading, this pint had been decorated with bright red mistletoe for the holidays, something that effectively caught my eye while glancing over the contents of my grocer's freezer. The majority of my recent reviews on peppermint-inspired creations have revolved around the popular striped candy, but this will be my first flavor based on combining the candy with chocolate.


Twisting off the familiar brown lid revealed a first layer that looked strikingly similar to that of Chocolate Chip Stracciatella, also made by Talenti. Although the official description can't be found on the pint's exterior or online, it appears as they've combined their patented tiny dark chocolate chips with a bright white peppermint gelato. It's been a while since I've experienced this ice cream that I've previously referred to as crunchy. The consistency of Talenti's gelato, especially coming off a hiatus, is always impressive. After coming to terms with the fact that I'm not going to uncover another Sea Salt Caramel, it's much easier to enjoy some of Talenti's more subtle selections.


The smooth gelato peels back with ease and I get a whiff of the mint meandering upwards out of the pint. The all-white peppermint base has the same familiar cooling sensation that others possess, incorporating the precise amount of sweetness to offset the overpowering herb. Although you shouldn't expect to uncover any of the large chocolate chips found in containers of Graeter's, these flecks of top-notch chocolate are incorporated into nearly every bite. The tiny pieces give each spoonful a rich, pleasant aftertaste. For some reason, these chips meshed much better with the peppermint gelato than they did with the coffee or black raspberry bases found in other flavors.


Where I Found It: Publix
Grade: C