.

Showing posts with label Turkey Hill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Turkey Hill. Show all posts

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Key Lime Pie (Limited Edition)


Key lime ice creams have been a bit of a conundrum for us over the existence of this blog. Some companies are able to incorporate the tart fruit from Florida with little problem, while others have failed miserably. Even though it took nearly all month to find Turkey Hill’s Key Lime Pie, I was excited to see they had once again opted for a taste of summer to act as December's limited edition; similar to what they did last year with Coconut Cream Pie. This combination of lime flavored ice cream with graham pieces and a key lime swirl comes in at just 150 calories and looked promising from the illustration on the outside of the carton.


With the lid removed, the first layer was made up of a light green base that already showed plenty of the graham pieces, but as soon as the first few layers were scooped into a bowl, we got our first glimpse of the thick, key lime swirl. While the lime flavored ice cream started out sour, sugar soon rushed to the rescue to assist in balancing everything out. Due to the large amounts of graham cracker, the soft, pie crust impersonators are involved in nearly every bite and do wonders texturally. Although not found as often, Turkey Hill’s latest limited edition reaches its full potential when the key lime swirl comes into play. Adding another element of tartness, this brings another level of authenticity, but doesn’t compromise the balance between sweet and sour. Add Turkey Hill to the list of companies that managed not to mess up key lime ice cream.


Where I Found It: Kroger
Grade: B

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Lady Liberty Mint


Because of the holiday season, the majority of the mint flavored ice creams I've had recently revolved around the red and white striped candy, but after running across this rarity in my ice cream aisle, I couldn't resist going green. Although I'm not sure of the inspiration behind this particular carton, Turkey Hill pays homage to the Statue of Liberty with Lady Liberty Mint, a mint chocolate ice cream with chocolate cake crunches and crunchy chocolate cookie swirl. Even boasting a slew of statue fun facts on the back of the container, I don't make it through many before skipping straight ahead to tearing the lid off.


After removing the lid dedicated to America's symbol of freedom and democracy, the light green first layer has me yearning for more. Luckily, from prior experience, I've found Turkey Hill doesn't like to show their hand initially. Most of the their cartons containing a swirl tend to concentrate a high quantity into the middle layer, which means most is left to the imagination before breaking ground. The 170 calories per serving is pretty consistent with other Turkey Hill flavors, and is confirmed by the soft, fluffy feel as I scoop some into a bowl. As I had anticipated, the deeper I dug into this carton, the more the enormous crunchy chocolate cookie swirl came into play. Chocolate cookie swirls are among my favorite, and have heavily effected the scores of flavors like Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Therapy, as well as their own Double Dunker.


Bringing my first bite up to my mouth, it's hard to ignore the intense smell of the aromatic herb, more so than with the other mint selections I've recently had. The base ice cream is nice and sweet, containing a strong cooling effect that begins to spread around the inside of my mouth. Although it's not a trait that I appreciate, the smooth, yet fluffy consistency helps alleviate the sensation. As you can see from the pictures, Turkey Hill isn't shy with the amount of chocolate cookies and cake they've shoved inside. The tiny chocolate cake crunchies are almost too small to notice, but the soft pieces of cake inside the slightly crunchy coating add a bit of texture and taste.


Where the French gave America The Statue of Liberty as a gift, Turkey Hill gives us the crunchy chocolate cookie swirl, and to someone who enjoys ice cream, something nearly as valuable. This thick, rich and chocolatey swirl comes in extra-large layers and is just as impressive as the cinnamon, graham cracker swirl found in their Pumpkin Pie. Each mouthful of flaky chocolate cookie that I taste takes me on a trip, with both taste and texture. Although mint flavored ice cream doesn't typically have the ability to truly excel, Turkey Hill has finally found a way to free this ice cream from it's usual ceiling.


Where I Found It: Kroger
Grade: B

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Eggnog (Seasonal Favorite Limited Edition)


The holiday season has brought us a handful of pumpkin, peppermint and most recently, eggnog selections. Edy's Eggnog had been too mellow to hold my attention, while Talenti's Old World Eggnog had finally done the cool Christmas beverage justice. Although it took a while to track down, I was finally able to procure a container of Turkey Hill's version. This seasonal favorite takes rich eggnog ice cream with rum flavoring and spicy nutmeg. In the words of Turkey Hill, "What could be more enjoyable on a winter night than a warm, cozy fire and a bowl of Turkey Hill ice cream packed with the classic taste you loved as a kid?"


The problem with most eggnog flavored ice creams and gelatos is the lack of excitement. The first few bites are typically enjoyable, but it tends to go downhill after that. Hopefully the traces of smooth rum flavor, perfectly balanced with the warmth of nutmeg will assist Turkey Hill's rendition in winning me over. Taking the top off reveals a first layer that looks nearly identical to that of Edy's, with only a few flecks of nutmeg breaking up the off-white base. At 140 calories per serving, the light, fluffy consistency transfers easily from the carton to the bowl.


The consistency is the same great feel found in other flavors from Turkey Hill, but following my first bite, the smooth, equally balanced flavor stands out. Allowing more rum to come through than it's competitors, Turkey Hill's version isn't shy with the alcohol. They've managed to incorporate the rum in a way that doesn't hinder the overall flavor, but dramatically enhances it. Granted this is a complex flavor that I have enjoyed during the month of December, the end result is just a bit unexciting in comparison to other offerings. Although this is superior to Edy's version, it can't quite live up to the high standards set by Talenti's super premium gelato.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: D

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Double Dunker


Most cookie dough creations are fairly straightforward. While most companies typically take vanilla ice cream and combine it with their chunks of cookie dough, even Turkey Hill's standard Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough differed from the norm. Replacing the standard vanilla base with one infused with brown sugar and molasses proved to be a worthy substitute for the more traditional method. Turkey Hill went even further with the variations when it came to their Double Dunker flavor. For this carton they've taken a mocha ice cream and swirled it with chewy cookie dough and a crunchy chocolate cookie swirl.


For a flavor with sizable mix-ins like cookie dough and a chocolate cookie swirl, the 180 calories per serving seems too good to be true. After removing the top and scooping some into a bowl, the light brown ice cream is so infiltrated with the cookie swirl that it's nearly impossible to see any of the cookie dough pieces inside. Grabbing the mocha base first, the nice subtle combination of coffee and chocolate provides an outstanding foundation to build upon. Although not overly complicated, the base leads with the sweet, richness of chocolate and finishes with that familiar creamy sweetness of coffee. It's hard to find much of the mocha base on it's own seeing as how thick the stripes of cookie are inside this carton. Similar to the chocolate cookie swirl found in Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Therapy or Milk & Cookies, the texture and taste provided by this component is incredible.


The rich, flaky swirl provides an intense chocolate flavor, all while adding a nice complimentary texture to the fluffy ice cream. Eventually the cookie swirl breaks down into the granulated feel that I've learned to love. The result is one of the best swirls I've ever come across, one that would enhance nearly any base it was paired with. Just this duo would have been more than sufficient, but Turkey Hill also felt like they needed to include their chocolate chip cookie dough chunks. Much like in their Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough flavor, these have mini-chips inside them and the soft, chewy exterior break down easily. This unique combination comes together to create one of the best cookie dough flavors I've found.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: B

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Coconut Cream Pie (Limited Edition)


Some people enjoy getting away for the holidays. Instead of spending time with friends and family, they'd much rather bask in the sun with a drink in their hand and forget about the flurrying snow back home. Turkey Hill's limited edition offering for the month of December is catered towards these people. To help alleviate the chill of the Winter months for those who can't seem to make it to warmer weather this Christmas, Coconut Cream Pie is intended to hold us over until the calendar turns. Joining their other current limited-edition offering, Pumpkin Pie, these two dessert-inspired delicacies will both be featured in grocer's freezers throughout the remainder of 2012.


Most of the coconut based ice creams I've reviewed on this blog, such as New Orleans Ice Cream Company's Toasted Coconut, Blue Bell's Coconut Fudge, and Coconut Macaroon from Häagen-Dazs, have all received rather high scores, so I'm looking forward to Turkey Hill's latest limited edition. Combining creamy coconut ice cream with coconut cream pie pieces, a single serving will only set you back 170 calories. Removing the limited edition lid reveals a light colored base that looks very similar to the other coconut ice creams I've sampled. Turkey Hill is among the best at retaining a fluffy feel, but still having a substantial consistency. I scoop myself a healthy portion into a bowl and dig in.


The luscious, coconut ice cream from Turkey Hill is a great consistency for a non-super premium option. Completely void of any gummy texture, the subtle sweetness from this base is something I've learned to appreciate through my exploration of all coconut ice creams. Although it begins mild, this has a strong coconut aftertaste as well as a bit of pulp left over on the back end. There wasn't quite as much as you'd find left over in a bite of Toasted Coconut from New Orleans Ice Cream Company, but just enough to make the texture authentic and interesting. Rivaling the toasted coconut flesh left on top of the actual dessert, this bit of pulp adds the perfect parting note to each bite.


The overall flavor wasn't overly complex, but Turkey Hill tries to make up for the fact by adding pieces of actual coconut cream pie. Typically the swirls found inside containers from Turkey Hill are among the most impressive you'll find, but they've decided to forgo that approach in this limited edition offering. These round mounds of coconut cream pie pictured above are the extent of the mix-ins you'll find inside Coconut Cream Pie, but luckily, they're about as accurate as you could hope for. The dense, chewy pieces of pie add some needed sweetness, as well as some cake flavoring to the mild coconut base. Although this can't quite compete with the stellar performance of their Pumpkin Pie, it isn't too far behind either.


Where I Found It: Kroger
Grade: B

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Raspberry Shortcake (Limited Edition)


Once again I was able to snag another limited edition carton from Turkey Hill. Even though it had received a few mediocre reader reviews, I still had to give it a shot. Raspberry Shortcake is described as vanilla ice cream with shortcake pieces and a raspberry swirl.


This 150 calorie per serving premium ice cream may feature a vanilla base, but good luck getting any by itself. This entire carton is loaded with enough raspberry swirl and pieces of shortcake that you won’t have any bites of pure ice cream. The purple raspberry swirl seems like a sweet, concentrated syrup and is balanced out nicely by the vanilla ice cream.


The finishing touch of this flavor comes in the form of the soft, fluffy shortbread pieces tossed in. These aren’t exactly exploding with taste, but small notes of butter and sugar manage to come through. Even though I came into one not expecting much, Turkey Hill still manages to make one of the better ice creams featuring a fruit swirl that I’ve found.


Where I Found It: Food Lion
Grade: B

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Pennsylvania Dutch Pretzel (Limited Edition)


As you’ve probably picked up on by now, I usually travel with a cooler on some of my long business trips where I know I’ll be passing by supermarkets and scoop shops I wouldn’t normally have access to. At the same Food Lion that I was able to score Ben & Jerry’s latest release, Scotchy Scotch Scotch I also found a limited edition Turkey Hill flavor I’d been dying to get my hands on: Pennsylvania Dutch Pretzel. Turkey Hill manages to keep this combination of brown sugar flavored ice cream with choco pretzels and a pretzel swirl to a mere 190 calories per serving. The pretzel swirl contained in Candy Bar Pie (which still remains exiled to scoop shops after its release in pint form was pushed back) was one of my favorites, so hopefully Turkey Hill’s version can be just as effective.


Similar to the base used in their Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Turkey Hill uses brown sugar instead of a standard vanilla. Once again, the slight flavoring of molasses does wonders for the overall taste and as usual, the consistency of Turkey Hill’s ice cream is ideal for a premium ice cream. The chocolate covered pretzel pieces (while a small percentage were soggy) provided a crunchy texture with a rich, chocolate finish. There were also enough of them that they managed to make their way into almost every single bite. The last component, and my personal favorite part of this limited edition flavor, was the pretzel swirl. This was neither sweet nor savory, but instead balanced somewhere in between with just enough flavoring to let you know it was made of pulverized pretzels. The real crowning achievement of the swirl was the unique, gritty texture it added. With that said, this is definitely a limited edition worth trying if you happen to run across a carton.


Where I Found It: Food Lion
Grade: A

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough


Although not readily available in my area, I've made it a priority to seek out some more selections from Turkey Hill. It seems to be a common occurrence lately for fellow ice cream connoisseurs to leave comments on the Review Requests portion of the page recommending a flavor from the ice cream imported from Lancaster County. After trying their limited edition Pumpkin Pie and one of their original flavors, Party Cake, I was ready to turn to the people to decide which offering to take on next. Seeing as how I've been tearing through the cookie dough selections from nearly every major manufacturer, I ultimately decided to add Turkey Hill to the list.


Companies have taken a handful of different approaches in arranging their cookie dough concepts. While the most difficult decision typically seems to be whether or not the chocolate chips should be included on the inside of the cookie balls or only put outside in the vanilla ice cream, Turkey Hill has veered from the dough status quo. Instead of the traditional vanilla ice cream, they've taken a blend of brown sugar and molasses flavored ice cream with chewy cookie dough and dark chocolate chips. Although I'm not entirely sure where the inspiration came from that resulted in the deviation from the traditional vanilla base, this novel idea sounds enticing.


The first layer is riddled with shards of chocolate and even a few pieces of cookie dough show through the top. Although it looks like other cookie dough cotainers I've seen, it certainly doesn't share the same subtle smell. The scent of the molasses and brown sugar is almost as intriguing as the taste. Seeing as how the dark chocolate is so integrated into the base, it's nearly impossible to sample the ice cream void of any mix-ins, but the consistency is the first thing that catches my attention. The base is a nice thickness, and although it's not a super-premium by any means, packs all the flavor of a high butterfat brand. Neither the molasses or the brown sugar are overpowering, just mild and pleasant, providing the perfect canvas to show off these classic mix-ins. The dark chocolate chips add a richness and slight crunch to each bite, much like many of the chocolate chip creations from Talenti.


Before long I begin to run into the marble sized chunks of cookie dough. Much like those found in Blue Bell's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, these have the same soft exterior that eventually breaks down into a granulated mixture of butter and sugar. They also adopt the same method of not only placing chocolate chips in the base ice cream, but also in the actual cookie dough pieces. I'm still undecided on this approach, but it just doesn't feel right excluding them from the actual cookies, so I prefer this strategy. Although Turkey Hill's overall flavor and feel wasn't among the top, it was still able to hold it's own in a very competitive category. All at around half the calories of others.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: C

REVIEW: Turkey Hill Choco Mint Chip


Every once in a while, I find myself pacing up and down the ice cream aisles (and even visiting multiple grocery stores per trip) without seeing one selection that grabs my attention. On nights like those, I usually go with a simple flavor and then spice things up with my own mix-ins. While none of my local supermarkets seem to stock the exciting, limited edition flavors from Turkey Hill, they do carry a number of their straightforward options. With the taste of Publix Premium’s Peppermint Stick still fresh on my mind, I looked for yet another mint option to satiate my cravings. I had already experienced how great Turkey Hill’s mint ice cream could be in Lady Liberty Mint, but I had to settle for their Choco Mint Chip this time around.


This combination of cool mint ice cream with melt-in-your-mouth choco chips comes in at a reasonably priced 160 calories per serving, which means most everyone can fit multiple servings into their day if they plan accordingly. After removing the red lid, the first layer is reminiscent of the stuff I used to order at scoop shops as a kid. Turkey Hill leaves all the bells and whistles for Lady Liberty Mint and opts to stick to the basics with their Choco Mint Chip. Similar to the way Talenti does many of their flavors featuring chocolate chips, Turkey Hill uses chocolate shavings that are small and make their way into every bite.


Even though this is efficient for incorporating a bit of crunch into every bite, it also becomes a bit mundane after a while. They’ve managed to make their mint ice cream smooth, well balanced, and just potent enough to leave your mouth nice and chilly, and although the bits of chocolate add a rich finish to each bite, they aren’t quite complex enough to keep my attention for an extended amount of time. Regardless, this was exactly what I expected and continues one of Turkey Hill’s traditions of dependability even on less exciting flavor combinations.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: C

READER REVIEW: Bob's Review of Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie (Limited Edition)

The hunt for pumpkin ice cream continues and next on the list is Turkey Hill's exclusive Pumpkin Pie, which is released around the fall season where pumpkin really shines. So far I've had 6 different brands besides this one: Graeter's, Ben & Jerry's, Dairy Queen, Handel's and Cold Stone Creamery. At the end of this review I'll give you my personal rankings of all of them. I'm usually not a fan of buying larger containers, but this being the holiday season, I will split this into 2 servings and eat half at once and the other half the following week. As the reviews piled in and people continued to love this option, I had to give this a crack. So does Turkey Hill surprise the consumer? Lets find out!


Upon cracking the top, it looks like a very basic pumpkin base, and hints of a nice thick cinnamon swirl. Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie is labeled as pumpkin ice cream with a cinnamon graham cracker swirl. As I dug into my first bite, I would have to say the base was a notch above both Ben & Jerry's and Dairy Queen. Yes, it is an ice cream, but this had a richer, creamier pumpkin taste than both of those. It does not give you a rich cinnamon, nutmeg, or pumpkin pie spice flavoring like the Handel's or Cold Stone Creamery options provide, but it's a dominant, rich pumpkin taste. Th result is quite refreshing and leaves you wanting to dig right back in for bite number two without thinking twice.


As you dig further into the pint, as you can see in the picture above, the swirl starts to really pick up, and by pick up i mean it is loaded and throughout the entire quart. The further you dig, the deeper and thicker it shines. Now let me tell you this, this swirl is unlike any swirl I've had in any other ice cream. Its not only dense in flavor, but also provides a slight crunch to it as well for how thick it truly is. The rich, cinnamon sugar flavors are very strong and leaves a permanent hit on your taste buds. It's literally like someone took cinnamon and pure sugar with a touch of nutmeg and pumpkin pie spice and somehow infused it right into the ice cream. It honestly takes this flavor to another level. This really strikes the true taste of a pumpkin pie that you have on your dinner table at Thanksgiving with a dense graham cracker crust. Put all of that together and this is what you are savoring once the swirl hits.


Again, the swirl gets thick, dense, and is very profound. It looks and reminds me of Graeter's chocolate chips by how thick it is and how often you find it as you dig into the middle/bottom of the container. There are points where you get spoonfuls of nothing but a cinnamon sugar and graham cracker swirl loaded with flavor. This container covers what you would want. A good (not great) base, but amazing ribbons of swirls that packs the cinnamon-sugar, pumpkin spice, and graham cracker flavoring that leaves you diving in for more.

Update on my top Pumpkin Flavors:
1) Handel's Pumpkin
2) Cold Stone Creamery Pumpkin
3) Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie
4) Dairy Queen Pumpkin Pie Blizzard
5) Ben & Jerry's Pumpkin Cheesecake
6) Graeter's Pumpkin


Where Bob Found It: Wegmans
Grade: A