.

Showing posts with label Marshmallow. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Marshmallow. Show all posts

READER REVIEW: Steve's Review of Blue Bell Rocky Mountain Road

I'm not the biggest fan of Rocky Road ice cream, as the traditional combination of a chocolate base, chopped walnuts, and marshmallows comes off as a bit too basic for my mix-ins craving palate. But the description of Blue Bell's Rocky Mountain Road piqued my interest, since it seems to offer more than the basics. Blue Bell describes this flavor as A rich, dark chocolate ice cream combined with dark chocolate-coated peanuts, milk chocolate-coated pecans, white chocolate-coated almonds, and roasted walnuts, all surrounded by a flavorful marshmallow sauce swirl, and since I am a sucker for chocolate-coated nuts, well, I just had to indulge!


Tearing off the lid, I was greeted by a reasonably appealing sight: Chocolate ice cream with a generous swirl of white marshmallow. However, there was no evidence of the four different types of nuts that the description promised. Not to worry! As soon as my spoon slid in to the ice cream, a profusion of nuts was revealed, with the great bulk of them being the chocolate-covered varieties rather than the plain walnuts! Even better was the taste. Rather than the feared bland ordinary rocky road concoction, my mouth experienced the joyous sensation of chomping through dark chocolate, milk chocolate, and white chocolate coated nuts. The barrage of chocolate covered nuts never let up, top to bottom the container was full of them!


Furthermore, the profusion of these candied nuts blended very well with the base ice cream and the marshmallow swirl. The swirl was provided in just the right amount: Enough to add a nice sweet marshmallow flavor to the predominantly chocolate taste, but not too much so as to overwhelm it. Also, rather than being the advertised dark chocolate, the base had the look and taste of a lighter milk-chocolate ice cream, which I found very agreeable, as it contrasted nicely with the richer candy-chocolate taste of the nuts. Bottom line: If you like lots of chocolate-coated nut mix-ins, you can hardly do better than Rocky Mountain Road!


Where Steve Found It: Winn-Dixie
Steve's Grade: A

REVIEW: Jeni's Sweet Potato with Torched Marshmallows


After Jeni’s Loveless Biscuits + Peach Jam nearly stole the top overall spot on my all time favorite ice cream list, I had heightened expectations for the other pint I brought back with me from Nashville. Sweet Potato with Torched Marshmallows is broken down as pulverized roasted sweet potatoes (grown for us at Hirsch Fruit Farm in Chillicothe, Ohio) blended into grass-grazed cream with red-hot Vietnamese cinnamon and studded with made-from-scratch (blow torched) marshmallows. Sweet Potatoes are one of my favorite foods, both sweet and savory, so I was really looking forward to this one; especially at an easily manageable 220 calories per serving.


Like all the past hand packed pints I’ve bought from Jeni’s, this one was also filled to the brim with a pale orange ice cream that showed off the red-hot Vietnamese cinnamon flecks. The consistency is top-notch as expected and the taste is just as impressive. The initial flavoring can easily be mistaken for pumpkin, but once it fully develops, the distinguishable taste of a sweet potatoes come through. While it may sound strange, it was delicious. The large, made-from-scratch marshmallows were worthy sidekicks to the unique base and almost gave this the effect of a sweet potato pie ice with their blow torched exterior. While this couldn’t quite top the performance of Loveless Biscuits + Peach Jam, this was still an easy A.


Where I Found It: Jeni's 12 South Scoop Shop (Nashville, TN)
Grade: A

REVIEW: Trader Joe's S'mores Ice Cream Sandwiches


Sometime last month my small, but slowly expanding, hometown of Asheville, NC was graced with the presence of its first Trader Joe's location. I'd been meaning to swing by to pick up few things and browse their ice cream selection, but once I received a recommendation from one of my readers to try out their S'mores frozen sandwiches, I finally made the trip across town. Each box comes with four of these small, circular, individually wrapped sandwiches that Trader Joe's describes as graham crackers with marshmallow-chocolate swirl gelato and milk chocolate flakes.


These come in at 250 calories each, which is pretty consistent with many of the other novelty sandwiches and bars I've had. Unlike a real s'mores, Trader Joe's frozen versions utilize two super-soft, graham cracker cookies that offer little resistance to teeth before breaking through to the gelato stuffed in between. They offer all the taste of a graham cracker, but none of the crunch. The marshmallow-chocolate swirl gelato feels to be on the lighter side and melts down rather quickly. The chocolate is mostly drowned out by the sugary, marshmallow flavoring, but the small chocolate flakes help balance everything back out and provide an accurate frozen representation of the classic s'mores sandwich. While these didn't quite have what it took to earn an A, they were still well above average.


Where I Found It: Trader Joe's
Grade: B

REVIEW: Blue Bell Gingerbread House (Holiday Favorite Limited Edition)


While most companies have barely rolled out their Fall and Thanksgiving flavors, Blue Bell has wasted no time getting straight into the Christmas Spirit. After reading the description of this gold-rimmed beauty above, it seems like I've saved the last of Blue Bell's holiday favorite's flavors for last. Having previously reviewed Christmas Cookies, Pumpkin Pecan Spice and Peppermint, this half gallon of Gingerbread House combines cinnamon ice cream with gingerbread pieces, festive sprinkles, miniature marshmallows and a vanilla icing swirl together to create this succulent sounding selection. Besides the festive sprinkles that are also found in their Christmas Cookies flavor, this will be my first experience with nearly all of the components included inside this gingerbread based ice cream.


210 calories per serving seems like a small price to pay for the plethora of goodies packed inside this carton. After lifting off the lid, I'm left looking at a first layer that looks nearly identical to that of Christmas Cookies, perhaps only a slightly darker shade of beige as a result of the cinnamon base. This is one of the rare occurrences where a flavor shows it's entire hand from the beginning. The cinnamon ice cream is riddled with red and green sprinkles, loaded with small white pillows of marshmallows and not so effectively hidden hunks of real gingerbread. Much like their other seasonal selections, this is right in line with the consistency of previous Blue Bell flavors I've had.


As I begin to fill my bowl to the brim, my excitement waxes, while my patience wanes. I throw the scoop aside and grab a spoon to secure some of the cinnamon base. The thick and flavorful foundation is overly sweet, but incorporates just enough cinnamon spice to balance out the sugar. Seeing as how the base is so bombarded with other ingredients, it's really hard to taste only the cinnamon. The red and green sprinkles make their way into nearly every bite, adding a slight crunch that gives way to the subtle flavor of the Christmas colored candies, all while enhancing the aesthetics. The visible vanilla icing swirl adds even more texture and is certainly reminiscent of the piped icing lining gingerbread houses during the holidays.


Marshmallows are usually incorporated into ice cream in the form of a swirl, but after having a few of these, I'm willing to jump ship to the authentic mallow cylinders found in this container. Adding the unique, squishy texture that only marshmallows possess, these fluffy mix-ins set the stage for the highlight of the carton. As you can see from the pictures, every serving is loaded with a ton of gingerbread. These pieces bring back memories of the soft, chewy cookies found in Christmas Cookies. The unmistakable flavor of gingerbread is the perfect addition to all the sugar and cinnamon.


Don't expect to find stale, month old gingerbread house leftovers inside this one. These pieces taste fresh out of the oven, even retaining their pliability despite sitting in a half gallon of frozen ice cream. Although these pieces are larger than any of the other mix-ins and there's a decent amount of spice incorporated, the gingerbread only adds to the sweetness. My insatiable sweet tooth was highly impressed. So much so that Gingerbread House shot ahead of Dessert Trio in the Blue Bell rankings.


Where I Found It: Publix Super Markets
Grade: A

READER REVIEW: Steve's Review of Blue Bell Fudge Divinity (Holiday Favorite Limited Edition)

In the past, I have loved Blue Bell's Christmas season offerings, and when I noticed that they added a new one, Fudge Divinity, well, I just had to try it. The Informant's official review was complimentary, which piqued my interest, and I was especially intrigued by what a "marshmallow ice cream" might taste like, as i could not recall every having eaten this flavor of base, from Blue Bell or any other ice cream company. Combine this with the promise that Fudge Divinity contains roasted pecans and a milk chocolate swirl and I was primed to dig in.


Opening the lid, I noticed what looked like a typical vanilla-fudge type ice cream: An off-white colored base with a few swirls of chocolate syrup. Digging my spoon through the mix did reveal the pieces of roasted pecan and more milk chocolate swirl, which improved the visual aesthetics of the ice cream, but for someone who craves big chunks of mix-ins, not very impressive. However, what turned out to be quite impressive was the taste of Fudge Divinity once i got around to transferring some from spoon to mouth. The roasted pecan pieces were plentiful, as were the ribbons of milk chocolate. Even better, the milk chocolate ribbons blended very well with the ice cream and nuts, achieving a taste synergy I doubt could have been achieved had Blue Bell used one of their thicker, chewier fudge sauces instead. Best of all was the base: I am not a very big fan of marshmallows, as i find their taste too sweet and their texture too sticky and fluffy for my palette. And, I feared Blue Bell might try to pass off a vanilla base with a hint of marshmallow flavoring as a "marshmallow ice cream". But my goodness! Blue Bell has managed to create a base that is definitely marshmallow through-and-through, and yet has the rich, creamy texture of an ice cream, not the fluffy stickiness of actual marshmallow. From the first spoonful, I was taken aback by the rich flavor of this base, so much so that I actually preferred scoops that were almost all-base to ones that were mixes of the base and the nuts and chocolate sauce!


Overall, Fudge Divinity is a tasty treat. You really do get the experience of eating a good piece of fudge divinity candy. That said, I do have some qualms that prevent a top-level grade. Since the pecan pieces are small, they don't really add much flavor, rather they serve as a kind of crunchy experience in the mouth. Blue Bell should have used larger pecan chunks, of the kind they use in their Pecan Praline flavor. Also, I'm not sure why this flavor is in the Christmas lineup, as it doesn't seem to have much seasonal relevance. I couldn't help but notice that Fudge Divinity has taken the place of their awesome Gingerbread House flavor in this rotation, and it suffers by the comparison. And finally, I still prefer ice creams that are loaded with mix-ins, and this isn't one of those. For those reasons, I will eat several tubs of their A-graded Christmas Cookies before I revisit this flavor. Still, well worth the 3200 calories I gained by eating the tub.


Where Steve Found It: Walmart
Grade: B

REVIEW: Blue Bell Fudge Divinity (Holiday Favorite Limited Edition)


When I think of the best flavor combinations offered by Blue Bell Creamery, their Holiday Favorite collection immediately comes to mind. Featuring flavors like Banana Nut Bread, Christmas Cookies, Gingerbread House, Spiced Pumpkin Pecan and Peppermint, almost every single selection has received top marks from me, so you can imagine my excitement when Blue Bell announced they’d be adding another member to the lineup: Fudge Divinity. Although I’m not sure how this particular combination ties in with the holidays, marshmallow flavored ice cream, roasted pecans and milk chocolate sauce were more than enough to have me off looking for this latest release.


All of Blue Bell’s options seem to come in below the 200 calorie per serving threshold, but Fudge Divinity manages to come in right at 200 calories per serving, which is surprising considering there aren’t any large, dessert-like mix-ins. The marshmallow flavored ice cream used in here isn’t one that I’ve experienced from Blue Bell before, but one I’m very excited about trying. After getting rid of the gold lid, the first layer looked promising. While it was almost impossible to miss all the roasted pecans littered about, I was able to secure a bit of the base to serve as my first taste. Much like I’d imagined, Blue Bell does a pretty nice job with this uniquely flavored ice cream. The texture is thick and slightly sticky, while the taste is sweet and easily identifiable as marshmallow.


The bits of roasted pecans were enough to add a little crunch to most bites, but as nuts in ice cream often do, don’t really add much by themselves. Luckily, Blue Bell has finished off this flavor with one of their thick, visually appealing swirls. Forgoing the option for some overly decadent fudge sauce, Blue Bell instead chooses milk chocolate. This decision results in an equally impressive looking swirl without overpowering any taste buds when combined with the already-sweet marshmallow base. Instead, the smooth, milk chocolate only compliments the other components. While the overall experience was pleasant and I really enjoyed the creativity with Fudge Divinity’s base, it still wasn't able to compete with some of the other options in this Holiday Favorite lineup.


Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: B

READER REVIEW: Derek's Review of Good & Delish S'mores Swirl

I finally decided to stop into Walgreens to try Haagen Dazs' Pralines and Cream and a large variety of Delish ice cream caught my eye. Having never heard of the brand before, I was quite intrigued by a few of the offerings. The cream of the crop looked to be the S’mores Swirl, which was described as “marshmallow and chocolate ice cream swirled with dark chocolate chunks and a graham swirl.” Now I’ve never encountered a graham swirl I didn’t like. And if the marshmallow flavor was even half as good as that found in a true s’more I was in for a treat. At 260 calories a serving, I was hoping this unknown brand was comparable to that of its super premium counterparts.


I was put off by the thin layer of ice on top of the pint. There was no seal, which isn’t a necessity, but because the pint wasn’t packed to the brim it allowed for space for ice to gather. Undeterred, I went straight for the chocolate base. The ice had no impact on the consistency of ice cream whatsoever so it was quickly moot point. The chocolate flavor screamed of milk chocolate. It reminds me of that found in Ben and Jerry’s Peanut Butter World, which is one of my favorite bases. To be honest, this is one of the better chocolate bases I have ever had. It’s sweet, creamy, but not overpowering. The marshmallow base on the other hand was something entirely different. It has a fluffier, smoother consistency than the chocolate. It’s almost as if it was composed of 25% straight marshmallow fluff and 75% ice cream. The flavor was slightly artificial, but wow was it ever amazing. In terms of unique base flavors this definitely cracks the elite list. It’s very sweet, maybe even too sweet for some people but it’s perfectly balanced by the chocolate half. For me just a spoonful of the two bases was already enough to make this pint respectable.


The dark chocolate chips were everywhere and added that perfect crunch that is needed in such a creamy concoction. The pieces are slightly larger in size than those found in a lot of other brands and the dark chocolate aspect is definitely the correct choice in this setting. The graham swirl had been screaming at me since the beginning and I couldn’t hold back any longer.


This graham swirl is beyond remarkable. It’s like they took honey graham crackers and a heaping handful of brown sugar and mashed them together. The flavor is intense and the consistency is that of an unbaked, sugar-laded graham cracker crust. I was total unprepared for the flavor bombardment, but just a tiny bit of this swirl combined with the other components created the best recreation of s’mores flavor I have had to date. I was sure nothing could hold this back from being a perfect A. Unfortunately, the graham swirl was slightly lacking for what I would expect to find in a super premium ice cream. It was prominent at the top and the bottom, but as you can see there was very little throughout the middle half of the pint. I’m a recovering mix-in junkie, okay not recovering, so I will admit my bias. Regardless, this is a great pint and worth a try for anyone who wants a flashback to making s’mores around the camp fire.


Where Derek Found It: Walgreens
Derek's Grade: B

READER REVIEW: Carl's Review of 2nd St. Creamery Truck Stop Fudge


Unfortunately for me, 2nd Street Creamery isn't carried in my area and I got lucky finding it at a gas station on my way home from a trip about two hours away from where I actually live. I had a cooler in the back, so I bought some ice and the 3 flavors they had in the gas station. This was my second flavor of 2nd Street Creamery Ice Cream and I was looking forward it. I cracked open the pint and saw some of the fudge sauce and marshmallow swirl. My first taste of the chocolate base was great. I had never had 2nd Street's chocolate before and I must say it was perfect for my liking.


A few more spoonfuls in and that fudge sauce was just awesome. So creamy and good. The marshmallow swirl did get overpowered by all the chocolate going on, but you could still tell it was there but not as much as the chocolate.


I kept digging into the pint and then it seemed like I hit a geyser of fudge sauce and wow, just wow, it got even better. That fudge sauce was great. It was the favorite thing I loved about this pint. There was just so much of it in there.


Overall: I would say if you are a chocolate fan this is definitely something you should try if you can find it.

Where Carl Found It: Wawa Gas Station
Carl's Grade: B

READER REVIEW: Mo's Review of Turkey Hill Whoopie Pie (Limited Edition)

I tend to get a little wary of ice creams that contain cake pieces. Don’t get me wrong—I’ve seen plenty of companies pull it off in a very good way. But I’ve also seen my fair share of cake mix-in disasters, where the cake itself comes out dense and dry as the result of having been packed into a frozen encasement for months on end. In fact, a few months ago, I did a review of Turkey Hill’s Limited Edition Raspberry Shortcake where I ran into that very issue. The shortcake just didn’t do it for me and actually wound up detracting from an otherwise fantastic flavor.


It’s no wonder, then, that I decided to proceed with somewhat curbed expectations when I saw Turkey Hill’s Whoopie Pie flavor hit my supermarket shelves. Under normal circumstances, I probably would’ve passed on this particular offering, but there’s something about the words “limited edition” that motivate me to try flavors I’d otherwise most likely avoid. (Way to go, marketing folks.) So after seeing Whoopie Pie in my grocer’s freezer for a couple of weeks, I finally decided to fork over the three dollars and give it a whirl.


The flavor is described as “chocolate ice cream with whoopie pie pieces and creamy filling swirl.” When I first peeled back the lid, I was pleased to see some pie pieces already peeking through. And all it took was a tiny dip of the spoon to reveal the aforementioned white, marshmallow-colored swirl. The base of the ice cream is what I’d call a solid, tasty, classic chocolate. It’s not super rich, and it doesn’t smack you over the head with that intense chocolate flavor. It does, however, serve as a nice starting point for a flavor where the mix-ins are clearly designed to be the stars of the show.


So let’s talk about those mix-ins, starting with the swirl. Well, it looks like marshmallow, and I know it’s supposed to be whoopie pie filling, but to me, it doesn’t have a whole lot of taste. Part of the issue is that the chocolate base, though not overwhelming on its own, essentially overpowers it. And while it doesn’t detract from the overall flavor, it also doesn’t do much to jazz it up.


But while the swirl ended up being a bit of a disappointment, the whoopie pie pieces were the exact opposite: a pleasantly tasty surprise. Forget about being dry, bland, and overly chewy; these whoopie pie pieces are the best thing to come out of this ice cream. They’re soft and wonderfully cakey, and they’re very well-integrated throughout the carton. And because they’re a nice rich chocolate, they do a great job of amping up the more subtle flavor of the base. So there you have it: The one element I feared with regard to this ice cream was the aspect I wound up enjoying the most. And despite the lackluster swirl, given the price point and reasonable caloric value, I’d say this flavor is worth checking out.


Where Mo Found It: ShopRite
Mo's Grade: C

READER REVIEW: Elliot's Review of New Orleans Ice Cream Co. Mardi Gras Pie

New Orleans Ice Cream Company has a special place in my heart. I spent a few years living in New Orleans, which afforded me the opportunity to explore the local culinary specialties that inspired many of their distinct New Orleans themed flavors. After reading the in-depth reviews here on the ICI, I'd been coveting the Crescent City themed flavors for months before finally splurging and ordering some online.


Score! I was not disappointed. Like a fat kid at a buffet, I happily made my way through a dozen or so flavors with ease. The pint pictured here, Mardi Gras Pie, is my absolute favorite of theirs and one of my favorites overall.


Moon Pie lovers unite. If you haven't had a Moon Pie, you will want to try one after you taste Mardi Gras Pie. The marshmallow base is slow melting, but when it tempers, Katy, bar the gate! Patience is richly rewarded with one of the best flavor and texture experiences you'll find in a pint of ice cream. The marshmallow base and swirl combined with the stracciatella-like chocolate flakes and graham cracker are a perfect marriage. Cheap, lighter Moon Pie branded ice cream sandwiches don't come close to what you'll find here.


I took it upon myself to see what I could do to make this brand available locally, requesting that a local specialty grocer here in St. Louis begin carrying NOIC. Armed with the product request form available on NOIC's website and the love in my heart, I plead my case. The rest is history, and now NOIC is available in a number of these markets here in town, allowing me the privilege of turning friends and neighbors onto this fine brand.


Where Elliot Found It: New Orleans Ice Cream Co.
Elliot's Grade: A

READER REVIEW: Kenneth's Review of Ben & Jerry's Truffle Trifecta (Walgreens Exclusive)


I don't exactly live in the best town to find, obtain and sample new products. It took some time before the Walgreens-exclusive Truffle Trifecta from Ben & Jerry's showed up here. By that point, the excitement seemed to have died down. The flavor received unenthusiastic marks from almost every site, but I still had hope for it to deliver some satisfaction.


Based on the cover and its description, I'm expecting plenty of chocolate action, along with complementary flavors to break up the monotony. Given the nutritional content, it should come as little surprise that the chocolate base is quite dense and very indulgent. Though I initially find it rather uninteresting, its richness grows on me. By the time it starts to melt I grow increasingly fond. As for the mix-ins, which arrive in the form of various miniature truffles, a fair amount are packed in. One immediate disappointment is just how small they are, which leaves even less room for their fillings to speak. The only potential upside to their small scale is the possibility for more to show up. But like I said, their appearances are just frequent enough to make note of, not much else.


As for taste, the truffles provide more chocolate flavor from outer shells, which break apart with surprising ease. It's definitely a pleasing contrast to something like the stiff balls in Chocolate Peppermint Crunch. The caramel-filled truffles seem to show up the most in my pint, with the occasional fudge or marshmallow-filled ones being significantly less prominent. As for flavor, the chocolate shell has a smoother, milkier taste from the base. The caramel-filled truffles stand out the most to me, while the other two blend with the base a little too much. I do wish there was more to this ice cream than chocolate ice cream with tiny chocolates and a brief, occasional shift in flavor.


Truffle Trifecta definitely doesn't live up to what I imagined it would be. While the base is ultimately about what I'd like and expect, the mix-in's just don't put on much of a show. It's still pleasant, and I have no trouble working through the entire pint, but it's easy to feel a bit short-changed by the lack of innovation here. For taste and overall experience, it's a bit below the mark for Ben & Jerry's. Where it falls short the most is with regards to execution. Set that aside and you have an unexciting, but still-enjoyable pint.


Where Kenneth Found It: Walgreens
Kenneth's Grade: C