Showing posts with label Red Velvet. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Red Velvet. Show all posts
REVIEW: Blue Bunny Red Carpet Red Velvet Cake
The first time I tried Blue Bunny’s Red Carpet Red Velvet Cake was early in this blog’s existence. Since then, we’ve reviewed hundreds of ice cream and I have a better grasp on where things sit taste wise. My super-premium snobbery has waned over the past year and lately I’ve really enjoyed some of the lighter fares available. I’ve also learned that flavors are typically much better in carton form than in smaller pint sized portions.
With that said, I was ready to give this 150 calorie per serving combination of rich, red velvet cake flavored ice cream is elegantly paired with cream cheese frosting flavored ice cream and red velvet cake pieces. The premium ice creams are bold, flavorful and their easily identifiable as red velvet and cream cheese. The red velvet base really allows the chocolate involved to come through.
The small pillows of red velvet cake pieces are pretty consistent throughout the whole carton and come into play at least every other bite. These are even a deeper, darker red than the maroon ice cream surrounding them. While the result isn’t quite as impressive as some of the super-premium renditions, for the calories, it’s another solid option from Blue Bunny.
Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: B
REVIEW: Private Selection Southern Red Velvet Cake
As I was cruising through the freezer aisle at Kroger a few weeks back, I noticed that Private Selection had rolled out a slew of new flavors. After trying their Southern Recipe Banana Cream Pie and Denali Extreme Moose Tracks flavors, I don't hesitate to invest in an entire carton, especially when we're talking red velvet. I've had this particular cake flavor from Front Porch, New Orleans Ice Cream Company, Blue Bell, Ben & Jerry's and Blue Bunny, nearly all of which have received a high ranking. Private Selection has taken pieces of red velvet cake and folded it into rich cake batter ice cream for their version.
I release the sure seal tab and pull the back the top to reveal this luscious looking first layer. The off white ice cream is so riddled with red velvet cake debris that it gives the base a near-pink appearance. My first concern was that there wouldn't be any gaudy chunks of cake, but after I began to scoop some into a bowl, that concern quickly dissipated. Tipping the scales at 220 calories per serving, this comes in somewhere in the middle as far as denseness is concerned, but still peeled away with ease instead of resisting the edge of my spoon. Leaving the large pieces of cake for later, I collected a large specimen of the cake batter base for further analysis.
The descriptions lacks to mention the fact that this cake batter base is full of cream cheese icing. It's nearly impossible to get a bite without having the fury of frosting string up from the ice cream to my spoon. The thick, sticky ice cream sure feels premium, and after my first bite, packs a lot more flavor than I had anticipated. Seeing as I enjoy cream cheese in my frozen desserts, I welcomed the fact that Private Selection went heavy on the cream cheese aspect of red velvet cake. The combination of sweet cake batter ice cream, cream cheese frosting and tiny specks of cake created one of the most impressive red velvet bases I've had.
The complexity of the base caught me a bit off guard, especially seeing as how the other Private Selection bases had only been a vehicle for the mix-ins. The ice cream could have contained a bit less air and a bit more butterfat, but the above average base was more than adequate. So adequate in fact, that I didn't prematurely chase down the cake bits, but instead savored the sweet cake batter base for as long as I could. When I did get around to sampling the slivers of red velvet cake, these delectable tidbits were the perfect addition to the top-notch base. Sharing the same bright red color as the chunks found in red velvet flavors from New Orleans Ice Cream Company, they tasted similar to the chocolate-infused pieces from Front Porch's Scarlett Red Velvet.
The thick, dense and chewy pieces of cake took multiple bites to break down. Private Selection doesn't hold back with the cocoa in these chunks, creating a vibrantly colored cake full of chocolate flavoring. There weren't a ton, but the flecks throughout the entire carton more than made up for the fact. After trying this, along with some of their other flavors, Private Selection is starting to gain my respect. With all the new creations they've recently released, I can't wait to continue my exploration.
Where I Found It: Kroger
Grade: A
READER REVIEW: Kenneth's Review of Ben & Jerry's Red Velvet Cake
Here's a review from our friend over at The Retail Judge examining a flavor that I personally feel gets too much criticism and one I always enjoy, Ben & Jerry's Red Velvet Cake.
Flavor-wise, there isn't much to distinguish red velvet from other, similar desserts. Rather, the famous cake seems to attract more attention thanks to its color scheme (white offset by dark red). Either way, it remains a strong inspiration for use in other treats, including candy and ice cream. Ben & Jerry's take on such an implementation was one of my very first forays into their selection, so a revisit seemed reasonable.
Although red velvet cake tends to have a somewhat dark look, Ben & Jerry's Red Velvet Cake has a pale tone, overall. Pink is what comes to mind, more than anything. It's clear from the outset that there's plenty of cake pieces scattered throughout. Since this is a touted "Red Velvet Cake Batter" base, the immediately indulgent sweetness is both fitting and rewarding.
The consistency is dense and relatively filling, as far as sweet treats go. Though the cream cheese swirl blends seamlessly with the ice cream, it becomes easier to spot thanks to a more melted appearance. It brings a slight change in texture, reinforced by a reasonable amount of cake pieces. As you might expect, these provide more of that straightforward cake flavor, combined with a density not too far off from a lighter, less hefty brownie. This is more than likely a result of the surrounding ice cream.
Working my way through the pint lets me become acquainted to the initially, arguably overblown sweetness. Since we are dealing with cake batter ice cream and cream cheese, there's a good chance some will draw the line before finishing a single serving. But my taste buds are able to adjust, leading to a nice balance of flavor and texture. For as sweet as this stuff is, I do wish there was more of a cream cheese swirl, since it truly accentuates the experience of getting it, the ice cream and some cake pieces all together. Judging the ice cream for what it is, however, I find little to fault it with. It's tasty, indulgent and sure to keep you smiling down to the last scoop.
Where Kenneth Found It: Walgreens
Kenneth's Grade: B
REVIEW: New Orleans Ice Cream Co. Red Velvet Cake
Most companies use their own red velvet variation as a base, but considering New Orleans Ice Cream Co. has Creole Cream Cheese in their repertoire; they’ve chosen that to act as the building block for this flavor. This pint of red velvet cake ice cream, like many other super-premium varieties, contains 250 calories per serving and shares the same dense feel as the base-only foundation it uses. The slow-melting, heavy ice cream allows the richness of the cream cheese to fully envelop your mouth and successfully soak into the chunks of cake stuffed inside. Although it takes longer to encounter the whole pieces, small bits of the red cake make their way into every bite; effectively turning the entire ice cream a light shade of pink. These cake crumbs give each bite a texture that’s just as unique as the taste.
Almost every company has been able to produce impressive pieces of red velvet cake, but the pieces of New Orleans Ice Cream Co. are among the top. These blood-red spheres of cake require chewing to break down; providing a tremendous texture and a burst of genuine, cocoa-infused flavoring as they do. The small streaks of chocolate sauce drizzled throughout only enhance the authentic feel even further. The New Orleans Ice Cream Company left no component overlooked when creating their version of the classic dessert and have created a top-notch red velvet ice cream as a result.
Where I Found It: Ice Cream Source
Grade: A
REVIEW: Front Porch Scarlett Red Velvet
After the atrocity that was Sublime Key Lime from Front Porch, I had become turned off to this new local brand. It took months before I built up the courage to invest in another offering from this Mooresville, North Carolina based creamery. I've sampled red velvet selections from all over, so I decided to see how their Scarlett Red Velvet would stack up against the competition. Looking over the design of the pint's exterior, Front Porch describes their red velvet rendition as, "Red Velvet Ice Cream with Cake Pieces and Cream Cheese Swirl." After tearing off the top to this selection, I was greeted with some luscious looking ice cream and some dangerously dark chunks of cake.
Most of the other manufacturers pumping out pints of red velvet use fire engine red cake pieces, but that's not the case here. These look more like little bits of brownie. My only real concern is that this selection will share the same icy-consistency as Sublime Key Lime. As soon as my spoon hits the ice cream I can tell that won't be the case. The Front Porch red velvet ice cream base has a stout swirl of cream cheese and I collect a healthy dose of both for my first bite.
Front Porch really redeems themselves with this rich red velvet cake ice cream and cream cheese swirl. This base shares the same consistency with Blue Bell's Red Velvet, lacking the denseness delivered with a super premium ice cream like Ben & Jerry's, but I don't mind. The cream cheese swirl helps bring the base to the next level by adding a soft, goeey texture. Unless they fumble on their dark chunks of cake, this could be a respectable rebound. It doesn't take many bites before I find myself with a few of the lovely, little lumps lying on my spoon.
Similar to the size of a sugar cube, these bring a bite much larger than their bark. I wasn't remotely ready for the ridiculous amount of flavor these were packing. These weren't your standard soft, chewy pieces of cake. These were super dense and shared the almost the same consistency as cookie dough, but that wasn't even the highlight of these hunks of heaven. Front Porch decided to diverge from the direction most manufacturers took, and instead concentrate more towards the notes of cocoa in red velvet cake. This interesting approach really paid dividends. This resulted in a marvelous mixture of red velvet ice cream, cream cheese swirl and bits of red velvet brownies. I'm hoping this further proved that Sublime Key Lime was a fluke. Front Porch has again peaked my interest enough that I'll continue to travel through their Southern-inspired lineup.
Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: B
REVIEW: Friendly's Red Velvet Cake Sundae Xtreme
Friendly's isn't a brand we frequently see in North Carolina. There aren't any Friendly's restaurants anywhere near our location and only recently did we start seeing their products show up on shelves. Upon first spotting this brand, we made the mistake (or so we assumed at the time) of scooping up their Mint Cookie Collision as part of their Sundae Xtreme lineup. It wasn't until we closer analyzed the carton did we realize we were dealing with a frozen dairy dessert. Since then, we've tried many of their standard ice cream flavors and enjoyed nearly all of them. What we can't understand is why they exile all their great flavor ideas to end up as frozen dairy desserts, especially this delicious sounding Red Velvet Cake version.
This red velvet frozen dairy dessert with red velvet pieces and cream cheese swirl only contains 150 calories per serving, but we know the trade off comes with the subpar consistency of the base. Regardless, we consider ourselves red velvet junkies, so we still scooped some into a bowl for science. As expected, the frozen dairy dessert melted down at a fast pace starting immediately, but the sweetness of the large, moist red velvet cake pieces and thick stripes of cream cheese frosting sure helped distract our taste buds. If you love red velvet and are looking for a sweet treat without a ton of calories (like we were), this might be a decent option, but go for a super-premium option for the best overall experience.
Where I Found It: Ingles Markets
Grade: B
READER REVIEW: Jim's Review of Holey Cream Strawberry Dipped Donut with Red Velvet Cake, Moose Tracks and Long Island Raspberry Ice Creams
After profiling the New York based, Holey Cream Outrageous Ice Cream & Bake Shop a few weeks ago, I was able to encourage a fellow ice cream enthusiast to go check it out for himself. Here's how his experience went:
This was the inside, its pretty small; but that is to be expected. I can't imagine Manhattan is a cheap place to own property. So what you do is go in, look at their ice cream selection (which was quite large I have to say), order a Donut, a frosting for the donut, and your ice cream(s). I picked Red Velvet Cupcake, Moose Tracks, and Long Island Raspberry.
I'll start off with the donut. The donut was still warm when I got it. It may have been freshly made, but I didn't really notice. The options for icing are Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry. I thought Vanilla would be boring and Chocolate would be overpowering, so I went with Strawberry. The icing was delicious and coated the donut perfectly, but didn't overpower the rest of the creation. The donut was very light and worked great with the rest of the ice cream.
Moose Tracks: Vanilla ice cream, fudge swirl, and peanut butter cups. The vanilla ice cream was great and there was enough going on for it not to be boring. The swirl was thick and abundant and the peanut butter cups were more like little peanut butter truffles.
Long Island Raspberry: I normally don't go for fruity flavors, but it just seemed super refreshing because it was very warm, I had been walking for a while, and I would still be walking for a while. I'm not entirely sure what it was because I can’t find a description. I just know that it was tasty.
Red Velvet Cupcake: Ok this is the one that surprised me the most. I have had a few Red Velvet Cake ice creams in my day, but this just destroyed them all. The Red Velvet Cupcake pieces were chewy, abundant and stood out from the base very well.
Grade: A
READER REVIEW: Kenneth's Review of Blue Bell Red Velvet Cake
Red velvet cake is everywhere. Red velvet ice cream, red velvet filled chocolates, red velvet Pop Tarts; next we'll be seeing red velvet Oreos and red velvet Twinkie knock-offs. But I digress. Ben & Jerry's and Blue Bunny already worked their magic on me with their own red velvet ice creams, and now Blue Bell are playing a bit of catch-up. Though my exposure with Blue Bell has only peaked with their Gingerbread House and Homemade Vanilla flavors, both are at the tip-top of my favorites list. Needless to say, my expectations were fairly high for this little pint.
The aforementioned brands had a bit of distance between their respective executions. Where Ben & Jerry's seemed to value a more conservative approach (for once) with the amount of cake mixed in, Blue Bunny poured enough blood-red goodness to make any pre-Twilight vampire blush. Each result was solid in its own way, with the gravitation likely coming down to whether you want cake in your ice cream, or a helping of ice cream in a whole lot of cake. For the sake of comparison, Blue Bell's take is closer to the former. Pulling the lid off my pint reveals, first and foremost, a trench along the rim that makes me feel a bit short-changed. The relatively innocent color wasn't a massive reassurance either, what with a fairly pink base. Digging in reveals a tame amount of red velvet bites which, though not plentiful, appear nice and chunky.
Even if it's fairly basic, Blue Bell once again prove they know how to handle a good ice cream base. It's a nice vanilla flavor with faint traces of cocoa lingering about. Like Homemade Vanilla, it feels silky and tastes creamy, a combination that brings me to scoop up and savor every little lick. The actual pieces of cake feel a bit less like said dessert and more like red velvet brownie bites, which I'm sure someone will jump at the opportunity to release. Though enjoyable, the ice cream-to-bite ratio is a bit wary for me, especially after the eccentric bliss of something like Gingerbread House. Blue Bell have proven they know how to make quality ice cream. And make no mistake, this is another solid offering. But as far as replicating the effect of red velvet cake in ice cream, I think it falls a bit short. More cake and maybe even just a few hairs worth of swirls could've really brought this ice cream to life. As it stands, this is a decent flavor, but definitely not a frequent go-to product, even for the red velvet fiend inside of me.
Where Kenneth Found It: Walgreen's
Kenneth's Grade: C
REVIEW: Edy's Slow Churned Luscious Red Velvet Cake
Edy's recently started rolling out its Limited Edition Bakery Treats lineup, which includes Coffee & Cookies Delight, Cinnamon Bun Fun!, and the carton seen above, Luscious Red Velvet Cake. All of the Bakery Treats flavors we've seen so far seem to be Slow Churned only, but according to Edy's website, these will all be available as Grand versions as well.
One serving of this red velvet light ice cream with a cream cheese frosting swirl and red velvet cake pieces weighs in at 110 calories; suspiciously low for a flavor containing mix-ins and a swirl. The ice cream easily gave way to my scoop, stringing upwards and sticking to itself as I pulled the gooey, gummy base ice cream into a bowl. Luckily, the flavoring was far better than the consistency. The base was easily distinguishable as red velvet, and while the cake pieces and cream cheese swirl were minimal, they still helped out the overall theme.
If you're trying to shed a few pounds or prefer quantity over quality, this isn't a bad option. On the other hand, if you're looking for an above average red velvet cake ice cream experience, this probably isn't what you should seek out. Edy's Slow Churned Luscious Red Velvet Cake couldn't manage to rise above mediocrity.
Where I Found It: Walmart
Grade: C
Like most other mediocre flavors, I like to spice things up a bit. This red velvet bundt cake with cream cheese frosting and a cream cheese frosting center fit the bill nicely.
FREEZER FIND: Red Velvet Cake, A New Publix Premium Limited Edition Flavor
We're also interested to hear about the limited edition flavors from Publix and their Publix Premium line of ice cream, so we were very excited to see the latest: Red Velvet Cake. This one features scrumptious ice cream with spirals of cream cheese icing, rich red velvet cake pieces, and roasted pecans. We can't wait to get our hands on this one.



















